<p>I think Georgetown and Notre Dame are two Catholic colleges that are very accepting of non Catholics, but when looking at a college, fit is beyond acceptance. It’s also feeling like the culture of the school fits. If Liberty is a fit, then Georgetown, in Washington DC, would have an entirely different vibe.
If you like Liberty, and want to also consider secular universities, then the ones that also have other students that share your background are likely to feel like a fit. For some of the colleges where your credentials are at the high end of admission criteria, you may be eligible for merit aid, and they could be a very good fit for you personally. Another one to consider is Columbia College, Missouri. </p>