@sattut, I have provided at least some evidence to support my views. Do you have any to support yours?
BTW, if you bothered to read the body of the link, he breaks down the philosophy PhD program composition of Princeton+Berkeley, which should give a representative sample at top 10 philosophy programs as one is an elite private and the other an elite but big public.
And again, the intake in to any humanities PhD program is tiny, so I’m not sure what point restating that most humanities grads from top schools don’t enter PhD programs is suppose to make. Most humanities grads from non-elite colleges also don’t enter PhD programs.
I’m also interested in seeing the distribution at this top med school that you mentioned. I have also seen some, and they did not look even more lopsided than philosophy PhD programs at first glance.