“appreciate art”
You may want to slightly favor schools with art museums.
“love watching sports”
You might miss football at Skidmore. However, their hockey could make up for that.
“An attractive campus”
“The 25 Most Beautiful College Campuses in America” / Thrillist (article available online). From your list, Hamilton and Kenyon are included.
You are a strong candidate and may get into several of the colleges on your list (by SAT score, you are above the 75th percentile at half of them), so you might not need to add more than one or two admissions safeties. An excellent option in its own right, St. Lawrence is one school that could serve this role for you, though it is somewhat beyond your five hour limit. Denison is another. Be sure to show a sincere interest in every college you apply to.