Geez, full marks for thoroughness! Keep us updated because it’s hard to suggest schools without knowing how much merit aid you need. You might need a full-tuition scholarship by the time the dust settles.
Note that parents are often willing to break the bank to oblige their children’s college dreams, but you/they need to discover if they’re setting themselves up for future hardship. UMA-Amherst is quite acceptable for poli sci, if necessary. Your 32 ACT gives you full tuition at Alabama, too. Not exactly liberal arts colleges! but they’re not bad options, in a financial pinch.