Congratulations on your impressive accomplishments.
It seems that in the topsy-turvy world of college admissions sometimes seemingly smaller, and certainly less academic achievement matter more than one would expect - you know, the apocryphic story of a French horn player accepted to Yale/Harvard/Princeton, one of these, because the previous French horn player happened to be graduating that year.
You have so much to offer these colleges, and yet, who knows, maybe your fencing will be the decisive factor? At any rate, I recommend going through “The Only College Fencing Recruiting Thread You Need to Read” here on CC. It’s over 75 pages of posts so not a small task but I’m sure you’ll find some inspiration there.