My daughter is a current freshman at Colgate. She is leaning towards doing a CS major and a double minor. Her stats are close to yours and similar achievements (AP scholar, NHS etc). Fall 2020 the school will offer the no loan initiative as part of their third century plan which I think will mean upping the grants. The school is also expanding diversity in campus. Our combined income is more or less around 100K from family of 5. My daughter received the best FA from Colgate compared to RIT, RPI and Clarkson. We also considered Colgate’s active and wide network of alums who from what I researched are a great support for students after grad. Good luck with your search!