What's more important to colleges: Band or High Grades

<p>Hi. I'm a current sophomore, going into junior year, in a school band. I'm trying to decide if staying in is worth it or not.</p>

<p>I'm a clarinet player, somewhat decent (I'm in a 1st band, and I made mid-level region band), but nothing special. I love orchestral and "wind ensemble" music, but I've got some issues with the band. My directors are horribly egotistical, rude, and have an insane superiority complex. They have favorites, and I'm not among them. I'm fairly sure, in fact, that they dislike me. They are also incredibly inconsistent scheduling wise, creating ad hoc rehearsals the week, and sometimes the day of the rehearsal, giving me almost absolutely no time to plan. They also grade band incredibly hard, to the point where it's hard to maintain an A in band. It's incredibly unfair, and it's crushing my class rank because it isn't weighted.</p>

<p>I've got really, really good academics and whatnot. I'm looking at my Eagle Scout, NHS, and some other assorted extracurriculers (I've been in scouts for over 5 years, and plan on continuing until college). I'd like to get into a nationally acclaimed college. I don't know what would hurt me more - the effect band is having on my GPA, or the way it would look if I quit half-way through high school, but with a much higher GPA and class rank(potentially top 10 people, top 2% if I quit - top 4% maybe otherwise).</p>

<p>As a sidenote, most of my section is quitting because they despise the directors, much like me, next year. I'm fairly certain that I would be on leadership if I stayed, but I've already got leadership credentials through other organizations. </p>

<p>It's a choice between horrible directors and a lower GPA and class rank, or quitting band, leaving an activity half-way through high school, but with a higher GPA, class rank, and more AP test scores.</p>

<p>P.E. and Fine Arts credits aren't a concern at this point in time.</p>

<p>Help?</p>

<p>Go for the academics, hands down. There will billions of band players applying to college.</p>

<p>Academics. You can always find something else to replace band. You already have other activities. It sounds like leaving band would be a smart choice.</p>

<p>As a parent if you were my kid I’d ask to ignore colleges for a second and ask you what your preference would be without colleges in the picture … and recommend you do that. Your academics will be terrific either way so either decision should be fine.</p>

<p>If you don’t enjoy band, drop it. If you do, keep it. Don’t worry about what it will do to your college profile.</p>

<p>If you are not enjoying it, drop it.</p>

<p>Grades are MUCH more important. Replace band with another music EC or another passion.</p>