The fact one has the contrary view and sticks to it, gains zip from others’ perspectives, bestows no “right” on that view.
CC tends to freely admit they don’t now how it works, but still insist it works a certain way, fails because of that, and should be fixed as “they” say so.
The problem, imo, isn’t admissions ‘generalists,’ most of the people I know have a variety of relevant academic backgrounds/experiences, plus deep knowledge of the U and what it takes to succeed at that school. i know OP disagrees.