My two cents:
- For the most part, I don’t think the CTCL are all among the most rigorous schools in the country, although many fine schools are on the list.
- CTCL are mentioned quite a bit on CC.
- The CTCL are generally smaller LACs and not every student is looking for a LAC.
- IMO the CTCL is a group of schools that has basically been put together as a great marketing opportunity. There are many wonderful LACs (including a number that are higher rated if that matters) that are not on the CTCL list. Any student interested in a LAC should read the CTCL list but should also look beyond that list and consider other LACs as well.
- The whole idea is to find the right fit for each student. The CTCL can be great fits for someone who wants a LAC and may be looking for merit aid but they may not be not such great fits for others (ex. my S visited one LAC and felt it was too small for him). There is no one right answer for everyone.
- Neither one of my kids went to a CTCL and believe me, both of their lives were changed for the better by their college experiences. IMO it is all about finding the best fit in an affordable school.