<p>I was a member if the inaugural class and I was an Olin Partner (one of 30 students who spent my first year out of high school developing the curriculum, student life etc. before I became a freshman my 2nd year). What you posted was totally true for you and this is true for me. Some of my thoughts:</p>
<p>1) Lack of alumni network
This is a bigger issue then I wish it was and probably not as big of an issue as you think it is. </p>
<p>When I went to Olin, there were no alumni. So, Olin recruited our parents to act as alumni (faculty and staff also used any connections they could). Many students got internships in the early years through parents who were impressed with Olin and convinced their companies (IBM is one example) to hire Olin students. During my time at Olin I interned all five summers at the following jobs: my local city engineering department, State Farms systems engineering department, doing user-centered-ish stuff for a heart surgeon in Ohio, Lockheed Martin (Systems engineering), Boeing (Plant & Facilities Engineering). Granted, I was pretty much the first Olin student to work at each of these companies but they gave me a chance and it worked out. And now other students have worked at many of those places.</p>
<p>Now there are 3 classes of alumni, now that is only about ~200 alumni but its way more than 0. If we had a bigger network, it would be better for sure, but we do have a very strategically placed network. If you want to work at google, yahoo, ideo, ibm, boeing, and so many others, we have alumni there. However, if you want to work in a smaller town or in the middle of the US, you will probably have to forge your own way.</p>
<p>The hardest thing for Olin students will be getting your foot in the door. Frankly most companies still havent heard at Olin. When I worked at Lockheed Martin some interns got a hold of an HR handbook that listed the breakdown from recruiting. HR had quotas saying that they had to recruit something like 80% of all interns from 25 target schools. The interesting thing about these schools is that it wasnt MIT, Caltech, etc, but local schools like University of Central FL. Olin of course wasnt on their preferred school list. That more than a lack of alums could hurt Olin students chances when applying to work at huge companies with intricate HR policies.</p>
<p>2) Lack of diversity
I guess this depends what you mean by diversity. You say you dont mean just race. Well, Olin had something like 85% of students out of state when I attended. And coming from the Midwest it was about all the cultural diversity I could handle at once. Where I come from about 95% or more of the students from my high school went to school instate. At Olin you do have a strange diversity. Everyone has a passion for math and science, and everyone has passions outside of math and since. Ive found that the opinions of my classmates on day to day life issues vary wildly. We may agree on project based learning but it often ends there ;-) I do think Olins interactions with Babson and Wellesley are very important thought. Cross-registering or spending time at those schools gives you access to a diversity of priorities and learning styles that is very important.</p>
<p>Could Olin be more diverse if it was liberal arts or state school, yes, but then it probably could not do other things as well.</p>
<p>3) Lack of faculty/facility
You said, a key point of engineering is research. I completely agree with this. Now I havent attended MIT or a school with a graduate program but my impression is that at schools with grad programs, grad students do most of the research. At Olin, there are no grad students so undergraduates have many, many opportunities to do research. All of our professors do research and it is all open to student participation. I would guess around 50% of Olin students do at least one semester of research during their time (though this might be different now it was that way when I attended). True, we only have a small number of faculty, so the sheer number and type of opportunities is less than a larger school. Our labs may not be renowned but many of our faculty are.</p>
<p>We dont have as much space or labs as bigger schools, that is something you sacrifice for a smaller school environment.</p>
<p>However, having a renowned lab and Nobel laureates is not a prerequisite for exciting job/research opportunities from professors. Our professors will do whatever they can to help us out in our chosen areas of focus because they know us on a personal and academic level. I think Olin can give just as much as a bigger school. I think at any school its a matter of the student initiating and building a relationship with a professor.</p>
<p>4) Lack of the college experience
This one is totally subjective. What a college experience is to one person it is not to another person. To me, football games and large sporting events is a high school thing, not a college thing. However, I know if I had gone to a large state school I might see it differently. I dont think a particular experience is necessary for it to truly be college.</p>
<p>I do agree college is often about finding yourself. But I dont agree it has to be about finding yourself academically. You dont need to go to a liberal arts school to build social skills or be involved in social justice (I know you didnt say you did but Im explaining). At Olin we can and do cross register with Babson, Brandeis and Wellesley. We do take liberal arts courses. In almost every class you have to deal with presentation skills, teamwork, analysis and usually some drama and angst.</p>
<p>Maybe you will remember when your team won the national championship. Maybe Olin students will remember winning the Outreach award in the NASA competition or helping a high school FIRST team build their first robot, or pigging out on an Alex Davis Special or stopping the flood in the academic center. If you think Olin is all work and no fun. Or full of super responsible little adults you havent visited on a week-end or after 1am. We are generally nerdy and our idea of fun is different than others but we still have it ;-)</p>
<p>Why I choose Olin
My parents didnt save up for my college; they told me community college or a full-ride, you choose. So I worked hard in school and got 2 full rides. Actually the other school would have paid for everything and given me a stipend but I choose Olin for the culture and the chance. As I mentioned I was an Olin partner. That meant I got to work alongside experienced faculty and yet they listened when my task group recommended chemistry not be required for all engineering majors.</p>
<p>I thought I wanted to do engineering since I hated English and history but loved math and science. I liked Olin. When I went for candidates weekend I was enchanted. I thought the people I met there were the most interesting I had ever met. The chance to help design a school sounded cool (I had no idea what it would really be like). Projects are fun so I thought project-based learning sounded great too. I may have had slightly shallow reasons for choosing Olin, but the reasons mentioned early in the bullet points are some of the reasons I recommend it today.</p>