Why standardized tests (and college in general) are ruining a generation.

<p>November 30, 2010
College. College, college, college. **** you, college. You've successfully managed to completely obliterate any capacity young people had for independent thought. It is all but impossible to eavesdrop on any group of high school students for any amount of time without hearing about college. It doesn't matter whether they are talking about the parties they're gonna go to, how many times they are gonna get laid per week, or deciding which Ivy has the strongest academics. Like people haven't been trying to decide that one for a while. Seriously, try eavesdropping on some teenagers next time you're at Starbucks or at the mall. You are bound to hear Harvard metioned more often than the Yankees (okay, maybe not during baseball season).</p>

<p>Okay, I admit this rant was caused by the looming prospect of taking my first standardized test. Yes, in exactly 11 days, 9 hours and 6 minutes, I shall be taking the ACT. It seems to have become a rite of passage, your first standardized test. The College Board (a heart-felt **** You to them too, and God forbid this is, by some miracle, ever published in any way, shape, or form, 'cause I'd probably find myself banned from any respectable institution of higher learning in no time) seems to think it is perfectly alright to charge a kid something close to 90 dollars for the RIGHT to take a test that will decide whether you are worthy of going to a respectable college. And you know, having a sticker with their name on your bumper. Nevermind that most kids take both the ACT and the SAT multiple times. Nevermind that they also charge you 87 dollars a piece for AP exams. And I'm taking 4. Thats 348 dollars for those of you who can't add (Lord knows I just had to use a calculator for that). 348 dollars for what is basically a bunch of paperwork. And then colleges charge close to 100 dollars each for the right to fill out an application. No refunds if you don't get in. And if you're a part of the majority, you probably won't. I don't really know how these things work, but that doesnt sound very fair to me, because I doubt very many families have the amount of money needed to undertake all the college-related costs high school students have to pay. Sure, everyone in my school can afford it. We live comfortably in the suburbs of NY. But what about inner-city kids? What about kids from poorer states? What about minorities? It seems to me the system is all but designed to help the privileged get into college in spite of their perhaps equally talented under-privileged counterparts.</p>

<p>I have never doubted the importance of education. As my father says, "Education is the wisest investment you can make". However, education should be about personal enrichment, and the betterment of the self. It should never be about power, prestige, a car sticker and a higher income. And in that way, and even though it's a cliche to say it, college does get in the way of education in its purest form. College has completely eliminated the thrill of acquiring new knowledge for the sake of acquiring it, and instead has substituted it with a bunch of numbers and statistics, to the point where it wouldnt surprise me to hear a teenager introduce themselves as "John Doe, Junior, 3.0 GPA, 2100 SAT score". No longer is school about taking classes you like, joining sports you are good at, getting a job and going to Prom, with maybe some community service thrown in. Now it all boils down to "What's going to look better in my college application?". This has become a world of SAT tutors and guidance counselors, and writing coaches and admissions officers, and I honestly want no part of it, but I will still go to Dobbs Ferry High School on December 11th and do my very best to get the best possible score on the ACT, and when I'm done with them I'll go college visiting and I'll fall in love with one place, the way the students all look so smart and applied, and the way that pretty girl over there is smiling at me, and the way the leaves fall just so on the dirt path, and I'll apply to that one dream school, maybe even early-decision, and I'll jump with joy if I get word that yes, indeed, they would like to have me. And I will do this because, in some ways, I'm even worse than my college-crazed classmates, because I recognize the wrongness of it all, and I think I want no part of it, I say it to myself, try to force myself to believe it, the spitefulness of it all.</p>

<p>If i find out that I didnt do as well as i hoped I would do 11 days from now, I wont think of it as a world-ending event. It wont be the kind of Apocalypse Now failure would mean for some classmates, even some of my friends. I would try to learn from it, draw lessons from it, and move on. And if no college decides I'm worthy of their institution, then (and I'll say it like this because, in some occassions, one swear word says more than the most eloquent speech) **** them, I don't need no stinkin' college to succeed. Who even decides who is successful and who isn't? Is there some kind of higher power that goes "Oh, you went to Princeton? Please sir, come this way, and let me kneel before you while I'm at it" and "Oh no, you went to SUNY Purchase? Tsk, tsk, I'm afraid you;re not successful". Hell, I can move to Maine and become a lumberjack, and if I can make a decent living and buy a house, even if it's not that big, and (just maybe, and far into the future) marry a good woman and raise good kids, I'll consider myself successful. That's success, buddy, and no one can say that the cold-hearted lawyer from Harvard who lives in a loft in Manhattan's upper west side is more successful than me.</p>

<p>You seem to live in some sort of twisted bubble.</p>

<p>are you seriously going to argue that every high school-er has the same chance of getting into college? If you weren’t referring to that , please elaborate upon what this “bubble” im living in encompasses</p>

<p>Well, I agree that the Collegeboard is stupid, but i’m much more positive about ACT Inc.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Good attitude and i’ll support you all the way, bro. Do what you want instead of following the crowd as long as you’re happy. In 200 years everyone will be dead, buried in the dirt. So go and enjoy your life when your alive how ever you want to.</p>

<p>Hey, who said life is fair. For college admissions to some extent I do agree it is all numbers, But they do have to differentiate between students and these numbers do some in handy. The AP Program I have to disagree with you on that, its not just a bunch of paperwork it does show that a student who scores a 5 is likely to do better in college that the one who scored a 3. And yet again, I have to disagree on what you said about the that families with low income at time don’t get the chance to apply to college’s or take the SAT/ACT multiple times. I go to a public school in Florida, we have a great population of students that are not economically advantaged. But these students can take the SAT/ACT 3 times each with the help of waivers. For most of the universities these students are able to get waivers for the application fee too. And the county pays for all AP Exams. So it all boils down to how this student does in class. Even though I wouldn’t say a student who is from a family with a high income has the same chances say the one from a low income family. But the gap is closing in.</p>

<p>I really don’t know how it works in Florida so I can’t really say, but in Westchester County, the price of the AP exams is reduced from $87 to (I think) $68 for people who receive free lunch in their school. Maybe it would be worth it if most colleges actually DID allow students who got 4s and 5s on their APs to opt out of those classes</p>

<p>Man, the first time I took a standardized test, I just showed up, did my thing, and left. Relax. It’s not that scary. (I’m only saying this because it seems to me that you’re not actually offering some profound social commentary here; you’re just freaking out over the ACT.)</p>

<p>Also, your Apocalypse Now reference doesn’t make much sense. The film wasn’t about dealing with a small-scale personal disaster.</p>

<p>btw, I’m not trying to bait you or something. Just, really, don’t overthink it. Go with the flow.</p>

<p>College has consumed the majority of students (I’m including myself). I’m somewhat jealous of kids who don’t need to attend a “top-notch” college to get the job they want. Unfortunately, for some jobs, college plays a HUGE role in whether you recieve the job or not. Heck, I still have my 33 printed out I’m so happy about it…</p>

<p>Edit: This just came into my mind. Going to a “prestigious” college is a great achievement. It means the student worked hard and put forth the effort to achieve what they desired. If your not willing to work, you will not succed. It is really as simple as that.</p>

<p>What does UVA stand for?</p>

<p>To Ghostt: Touche, im kind of freaking out just a little bit. That doesn’t mean I don’ t think what i wrote (ranted?) about is completely true. And the Apocalypse Now reference refers to the fact that, for many kids, it WOULDNT be a small-scale personal disaster, but a full-blown “I’m not gonna amount to anything in life” meltdown.</p>

<p>To UVAorbust: No one said I’m not willing to work hard and put forth the effort necessary to succeed, thats not the point of my post (rant?).</p>

<p>To GreedIsGood: Lol</p>

<p>

I think I can help improve your essay scores, reasonable rates; PM me. :)</p>

<p>oh please, my college essay will look nothing like that. That’s just a rant i wrote in the middle in the night.</p>

<p>So go enrich yourself. Better yourself. Stop crying. If you are 16, you can drop out. The majority of kids in America never go to college. Try that.</p>

<p>It’s actually not that hard for poorer kids either…
I get fee waivers for everything. APs, SATs, ACTs, 14 college fee waivers…</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>No, I figured. There is some truth to what you’re saying, but I did think your moral indignation was also fuelled by some anxiety ;)</p>

<p>Don’t sweat it. The ACT/SAT really isn’t as important as it may look to you at the moment. I wish you good luck, of course, but it’s not worth stressing over.</p>