Why was I deferred?

<p>Decision: Deferred</p>

<p>Date applied: October 2009
Date decision postmarked/received: December 17, 2009</p>

<p>Stats:[ul]
[<em>] SAT Total: 2310 M: 790, CR: 750, WR: 770
[</em>] ACT: N/A
[<em>] SAT Subject Tests: Math 2: 680, US History: 740, English Lit: 730
[</em>] GPA-UW/W: 3.7/4.1
[<em>] Rank: Top 6%
[</em>]AP/IB classes: Euro History, US History, English Lang, Chemistry, Micro/Macro Economics, English Lit, US Gov, Calc AB
[/ul][ b]Subjective:[ul]
[<em>] Essays: Very good (AP Language said it was best she's read in a few years)
[</em>] Teacher Recs: Very good
[<em>] Counselor Rec: Good
[</em>] EC highlights: Piano for 10 years, guitar for 6, School jazz band for three years, medical missionary trips to Brazil (2 summers), math club, worked as web designer for a local business
[/ul][ b]Location/Person:
[ul]
[<em>] State or Country: FL
[</em>] School Type: Large public
[<em>] Ethnicity: White
[</em>] Gender: Male
[/ul]Other Factors, hook?: National Merit semifinalist (awaiting finalist notification)</p>

<p>General Comments, scholarship chances, status info, going to NEU...?: Did anyone else get deferred or rejected with similar stats? Is there something they were looking for that I didn't have? What do you think chances are for regular admission and hopefully merit $?</p>

<p>thats unbelievable i got in with way way wayt less impressive stats</p>

<p>yeah you shouldn’t just have gotten in, they should’ve given you at least a dean’s scholarship. i’d call admissions</p>

<p>maybe you didn’t show enough interest?</p>

<p>you treated them as a safety, and they wanted to put the fear of god into people in places like CC as to make them show respect when applying to their school</p>

<p>The problem is I didn’t treat them as a safety. I called multiple times to make sure I was getting all my materials in on time. I emailed my regional counselor. Plus, I attended the “Orientation weekend” in November. I flew up from Florida to Boston and attended the honors information meeting and all the business school programs. I think I showed a great deal of interest.</p>

<p>dramski, i got deffered with similar stats, slightly lower sats but great sat II’s, ECs and volunteer…i was so shocked and upset i dont understand what more i could have done. I also showed so much interest and went to the open house etc. I don’t know what to do because NEU was deffinitly one of my top schools :frowning: good luck, hopefully you’ll get in in April!</p>

<p>They thought you were treating them as a safety. You probably are applying to more difficult schools and they know it. Sometimes they take the gamble on rejecting/deferring a student an usually they’re right in their descision.</p>

<p>badromance: I know. This stinks. Good luck to you too.</p>

<p>And I haven’t applied to harder schools. The hardest schools I sent applications to are Tulane and Northeastern. I got into Tulane with a 22k annual scholarship, but Northeastern was (and is) my top choice, and I made an effort to ensure that they knew that.</p>

<p>Hmm well with stats like that you certainly have nothing to lose by applying to more difficult schools.</p>

<p>wow. that sucks, you’re more than qualified. Maybe contact admissions and see if there’s any way you can show your interest… I can’t imagine you wouldn’t get in regular decision.</p>

<p>Classic example of Tufts’ Syndrome, sorry man.</p>

<p>i would tell the admissions office that and i would think you’d get in RD with a scholarship</p>

<p>Here are my stats compared to yours and I got deferred as well</p>

<p>Decision: Deferred</p>

<p>Applied to the Business School</p>

<p>Stats:[ul]
[<em>] ACT: 26
[</em>] GPA-UW/W: 3.2/3.55
[<em>]AP/IB classes: Taking AP Macro/Micro Economics and AP Psychology
[/ul]Subjective:[/list]
[</em>] Essays: Very strong- wrote about experiences as a National ranked Scrabble player
[<em>] Teacher Recs: Never saw them but I would assume they’re pretty strong
[</em>] Counselor Rec: Never saw it but my guidance counselor knows me pretty well so probably good
[li] EC highlights: DECA for 4 years- Secretary, Historian, VP, President (Regional Winner and State Top 10)[/li]Academic Team for 4 years- Vice President and President (Captain of A-Team)
Italian Club for 4 years- Vice President and President
Business Honor Society
National Honor Society
FBLA
JV Tennis Captain for 3 Years
Varsity Tennis for 1 year
Nationally Ranked Scrabble Player
Went to New Orleans to build houses for a week, helped with numerous fundraisers for breast and brain cancer, Relay for Life</p>

<p>[<em>] State or Country: NY
[</em>] School Type: Public - 400+ kids in graduating class; strong academically
[<em>] Ethnicity: Caucasian
[</em>] Gender: Male
[/list]**Other Factors, hook?: Scrabble Essay, Did a 4 week summer program</p>

<p>**General Comments, scholarship chances, status info, going to NEU…?: I was at Northeastern this summer and I took a business class for a week and did a 3 week internship so I know the campus very well. I understand the competitiveness of the admission process and while it is not my top choice (Delaware is) but I would probably consider it to be my second choice and I hope I get accepted come regular decision time.</p>

<p>Why was I deferred?</p>

<p>I have a 4.0 and have taken every demanding course my high school offers…
(Class rank 11/326)</p>

<p>Junior Year-
AP Calc (A+, A)
AP US History(A, A+)
AP English (A, A)</p>

<p>Senior Year-
AP Chemistry (A+)
AP English (A)
Honors Physics (A+) and next semester I am switching into AP Physics (without taking the entire course…I want to show college admissions staff that I am looking to challenge myself)</p>

<p>I play Girls Varsity Lacrosse
I have received many Faculty Awards in Math and Science
I am in Interact Club, Student Council, Humanitarian Club, Debate Club, and in the Student Leadership Organization</p>

<p>I am not an excellent standardized test taker; however,
SATs-
630 Math
610 Writing (10 on my essay)
560 Critical Reading</p>

<p>ACTs-
31 Math
29 English
22 Reading
22 Science
(10 on my essay)</p>

<p>I was deferred to Regular Decision; however many other people from my school who are significantly lower than me with class rank and GPA were accepted. I am very concerned and confused on how this could be.</p>

<p>What do you think my chances for admission will be for RD? I am going to send the admissions office a letter that Northeastern is my top school, and I was selected to be a teacher’s assistant in my Physics class.</p>

<p>SAT -
620 Writing (*) not like that will make much of a difference.</p>

<p>Maybe they just want to see how the RD pool plays out to help them figure out how to allocate scholarship money.</p>

<p>NEU is trying to become very exclusive, it seems.</p>

<p>You need to make it clear to northeastern that it is your number 1. Ask your counselor how you can go about this.</p>

<p>It’s not being exclusive. First, it depends on the major you applied to. Very popular majors are much much harder to get into, because more people apply.</p>

<p>Second, it definitely is Tufts Syndrome. Middle-ranked schools and schools ranked well (but not top schools) sometimes will reject or defer very good students. The theory is that they are bound to get acceptances at other, better, schools. When a school is ranked, they look at the acceptance rate and the rate of people who decide to come. If they know someone could go to Yale, why would they waste an acceptance on them? It just hurts their rank when they know that student won’t come. If you for instance get into Brown EA, you’ll pull out your application at NEU, and voila! NEU isn’t worse off.</p>

<p>I’m not saying it’s a good policy, and obviously you should have got in. Chances are they will accept you for RD. Send admissions an email asking if there is any way you can increase your chances, etc etc. Make sure they know that if they accept you, you WILL go (even if its not 100% true).</p>