I wouldn’t but you can try.
A 31 is a very good score but you would be smart to have a list of test optional schools.
My other suggestion is to see if your soccer and softball skills are a match for the Division 3 schools, specifically the academic conferences like NESCAC. They typically do not proactively recruit but all the schools have full athletic programs and you should do the online recruiting questionnaires. Many NESCAC schools are test optional and virtually all are listed in the top 20 in the liberal arts college rankings. Patriot League is also another academic conference.
You probably also know you have huge advantage with catholic schools. Holy Cross would be a very safe bet, Boston College solid chance but ND and Georgetown not likely.
Where are you from? Which schools are you considering?