Would I be stupid for turning down the chance to do my year abroad at Notre Dame compared to northea

I strongly agree with all of this.

Rutgers, Goucher, and GMU also have fairly convenient locations, as noted above. In addition to its location near NYC, Rutgers has a strong history program and, as a Colonial College, has a long history itself.

After googling your options, I’m guessing you’re at East Anglia. Glancing over their list of options, Georgetown sticks out as a good school in a great location. It would be far and away the best choice if it’s an option.

There are some other universities on the list that combine stronger history programs than any of those above, including ND, with the classic American “college experience” – UNC in particular, but also Minnesota and the UCs. I’d take any of those over Notre Dame hands down, but YMMV.

https://www.uea.ac.uk/study/study-abroad/outgoing/study/north-america/united-states