You’ve got to understand that most schools report for enrolled students. First, you need to be admitted. And tippy tops are looking at sub-scores, not composite.
Brown does show admit stats (so do just a few others.) A whopping 7% of applicants scoring 29-32 are admitted, (compared with a 50% rate for 33-35.) (And similar low percents for OP’s SAT M.) But, they don’t show how scores fared within that range, nor how that breaks out by major or hooks- or the quality of their whole apps.
Dart and Penn show ACT for enrolled students, no further detail for within a range or by major. No assumptions should be made about a 32. Typical advice is be to be at the very top of the mid-range, at least, and have the right strengths in sub-scores.
There will need to be that something which pushes you over. It may not be a hook, may be your own accomplishments or insight, etc. Research and a few hs clubs may not be that push.
OP, can you answer a “Why Us?” sort of question for H and Y?