Yes, Again: Vanderbilt Vs. Emory

<p>I have decided that I want to add one of these two schools to my list and I CAN'T DECIDE. Both same size - ish, both semi-prestigious... help help!</p>

<p>Pros for Vanderbilt:
-- has an extensive Communications major that looks fabulous (kind of looking for something like this)
-- has guaranteed undergraduate housing
-- has more "school spirit"</p>

<p>Pros for Emory:
-- advantages of being right by Atlanta (except I don't have a car...o0)
-- has a co-major option for Journalism!
-- is in Georgia. This is a dumb reason I know, but I have really good friends going to school in Georgia, and also the teacher writing my letter of rec grew up in Georgia and I love her to bits. So that seems like a good sign from God, if you're looking at it that way.
-- has that 15 k cap-loan thing
-- looks a lot less snotty than Vanderbilt so far (I don't own a Gucchi bag. Sorry. X( )</p>

<p>idk about Vanderbilt but some comments on Emory: </p>

<p>Not having a car shouldn't be that much of a problem, because MARTA is semi-decent in the area. The Emory area isn't completely urban but there's stuff within walking distance. </p>

<p>I don't know why Georgia would be that special... XD I guess if you have friends going to Georgia State or Tech it might be fun, but especially if you're from Colorado the heat and humidity might bother you. </p>

<p>One downside about Emory is that it's a fairly small school with a fairly small campus. There's not a lot of school spirit, either, since sports is minimal and they don't have a football team. Emory is close to Little 5 Points, but the immediate area surrounding it isn't all that exciting.</p>

<p>Only one this site would someone say Vandy and Emory are only 'semi-prestigious'. Ugh...</p>

<p>Search YouTube for "fun at Emory"...it's classic!</p>

<p>
[quote]
-- looks a lot less snotty than Vanderbilt so far (I don't own a Gucchi bag. Sorry. X( )

[/quote]
You know, the unremitting portrayal on this board of Vanderbilt as a "snotty" place where one needs a Gucci bag to fit in - usually by people who've never set foot on campus - is pretty discouraging. It usually goes something like this: poster asks if Vandy's reputation as a haven for rich white Southern snobs is true. Several posters with personal experience at Vandy, either as students or parents, respond in the negative. And then someone posts that the richest, snobbiest b*tch at their high school goes to Vanderbilt, so of course the rumors are true.</p>

<p>Apologies if the OP has visited Vanderbilt and been singled out by snobs pointing and whispering about the lack of a Gucci bag. But if not - well, no kidding, "yes, again." </p>

<p>In truth, Emory and Vanderbilt have rather similar student bodies, and there are rich white snobs at both. But do they set the prevailing tone on campuses where the students have to be pretty freaking accomplished to be admitted? Only amongst themselves.
[quote]
both semi-prestigious

[/quote]
Funny!</p>

<p>Can the OP please send me by PM this "communications" program they think exists? Just curious, but my D turned down Vandy this past year because she couldn't find one faculty member on campus that could relate to what she wanted to study.....If it's new for 2009, my bad....</p>

<p>There are rich, snobby kids at both schools...the big difference we found when visiting was that the "rich, snobby kids" at Vandy tended to literally look you up and down when you walked down the street....at Emory they appeared too self-absorbed to care....</p>

<p>You may want to check out the admitted demographics of the class of 2008 when they are released....I think you will find that these two schools are becoming less similar than you think....</p>

<p>lol, if it redeems me at all, I did want to say "prestigious" but was like, Wait, I'm asking advice of the HYPS graduates of the future... (which I am NOT applying to o_o)... Didn't think anyone would call me on it but I guess I deserved it. <em>bows</em> I stand corrected.</p>

<p>As for the Vanderbilt jab - this one I'm not ashamed of, since I do actually have relatives in Tennessee who have confirmed the online rumors. No, I've never actually toured the campus, but if the people who even live in the state have a leery view of the student body, it can't be all fictional.</p>

<p>Sorry if I've raised any fur. And thanks for the constructive information - I really did ask sincerely, and I appreciate it.</p>

<p>I guess it must help to live life in a clueless fog. I have visited the Vanderbilt campus several times, and am far from put-together in the fashion magazine sense. If folks wanted to point and whisper, or look me up and down as I walked down the street, I give them plenty of reason. Yet I've never felt anything other than courtesy and even cordiality on that campus, from professionals and students alike. Ditto the West End of Nashville.</p>

<p>I realize it's pointless to uphold this position - but I'm going to anyway.</p>

<p>sure, here's the link to the communications page (and there appears to be a co-major option, too, I think) :)</p>

<p>Department</a> of Communication Studies</p>

<p>why pointless? it's good to know.</p>

<p>Pointless because I'm one of many posters who has said this over the 4-plus years I've been on the board - and it never seems to penetrate the dearly-held impression folks have of Vanderbilt. Though it's nice of you to think it's of some value! :)</p>

<p>It occurs to me that there must be a cohort of rich white snobs on every top 20 campus. But it's only at Vanderbilt that they're supposedly everywhere you look.</p>

<p>My D goes to Vandy. Not the snobby type...we don't have the money to be snobby. We would have beat that out of her if it were the case. Her ex- wanted to attend Vandy (loads of money) but couldn't get in (he also had tons of connections at Vandy but that doesn't really matter much). He ended up at Emory so the rich kid ended up at Emory and the poor kid at Vandy. Just one exception perhaps.</p>

<p>I like both schools, but think that they are pretty different experiences and generally attract different types of student personalities. Statistically, they are very close, but in feel they are quite different and, in Vanderbilt's case, much changed over the last decade. As others have noted above, old stereotypes persist, but they misrepresent the breadth of what Vandy is like today. </p>

<p>In another thread (I think it might also have been an Emory vs Vanderbilt comparison), a Vandy student (theOC89)weighed in with a pretty good description of what Vanderbilt is like today. I really wish that something like this were available for all colleges because this student gives pretty good insight into what goes on at the school and what it is like. If anybody has anything similar to post for Emory, then please do so. </p>

<p>Finally, perhaps theOC or another current Vanderbilt student will see this thread and add to theOC's earlier comments/descriptions which I repost below:</p>

<p>“Vanderbilt has arguably the best social scene out of any Top 20 school. The student body is incredibly balanced and driven. The classes are demanding so people are generally very focused on their work during the week, but on the weekends there will be tons of parties all over campus.</p>

<p>“There are about 6,000 undergrads which makes it a mid-sized school. It is big enough where you can always meet new people but small enough where you can see your friends around campus. The campus has a park-like feel (nice brick buildings surrounded by lots of trees). One of my favorite parts about Vanderbilt is the incredible geographic diversity – you will make friends from all across the country/world.</p>

<p>“There is no need for a car on campus. There are tons of great restaurants within walking distance. Most people typically like to stay on campus, but Thursday is the big night to go downtown. Generally, people will go to the Munchie Mart (mini-convenience store on campus) and buy “cab cash”. Downtown is about 2 miles from campus so it is generally really cheap when you split the fare with friends.</p>

<p>“Nashville has a lot of different "neighborhoods". Elliston place has lots of indie/alternative bands (Exit-In; The End); Hillsboro Village has lots of trendy bars/restaurants (Cabana is on the VandyCard). WestEnd/Midtown is the area around campus. The area that surrounds campus isn’t really southern at all, but downtown Nashville has much more of a country western sort of feel. Coming from NY, I found the downtown area to be small/southern but it has grown on me. Culturally, there is the Frist Center for the Visual Arts, TN Performing Arts Center, and the Nashville Symphony Orchestra. Lots of venues downtown for concerts including Ryman Auditorium (the old Grand Ole Opry venue) and the Summit Center. Nashville also has some professional sports teams – TN Titans (NFL), Nashville Predators (NHL), and the Nashville Sounds (Triple-A Baseball). Centennial Park is also a really nice area by campus (read/jog/makeout) which is around a block from campus (also home to the Parthenon – one of Nashville’s landmarks).</p>

<p>“Although Nashville has lots of social outlets, most people stay on campus during the weekends. Homecoming Quake and Rites of Spring are the biggest music festivals but Vanderbilt will generally bring bands on campus throughout the year. Rites of Spring is a great time and absolutely awesome festival. During Rites of Spring there will tons of partying, lots of dancing, and even some crowd surfing. The campus becomes electric.</p>

<p>“Vanderbilt has completed the “Freshmen Commons” – essentially they are brand-new residential colleges. The campus is very tight-knit and very few people live off-campus. Around 1/3 of guys join fraternities and around 1/2 of girls join sororities. Only the officers live in the houses (around six people). I’m independent but I have lots of friends who are Greek and everyone interacts well. The fraternities will generally have lots of theme parties where everybody gets dressed up (80s, Middle School, Anything But Clothes, Foam/Paint, Jungle, Gatsby, etc.). There are also lots of live bands and DJs for late night dance parties. Aside from the fraternities, there are also lots of parties in the upperclassmen suites. There will be tons of dance parties in Towers Suites or Morgan Lewis. There will also be lots of drinking games, especially Beirut/Beer Pong and Flip Cup.</p>

<p>“Lots of clubs downtown are 18+, but the bar scene is mostly popular among upperclassmen. On Tuesdays, Cabana/Sams/Sportsman in Hillsboro Village are very popular (the first two are on the Vandy Card). Demonbreun Street is very popular on Thursdays (especially The Tin Roof/Dan McGuiness) along with Buffalo Billiards and the Flying Saucer downtown. I’m not really into country music – but Roberts/Tootsies/The Stage are places to check of if that’s your scene. Boundary and Virago are also popular restaurants around campus and popular pregame spots. For margaritas, many people go to Las Palmas and there are several sushi places for sake bombing (these places are generally less strict on IDs).</p>

<p>“The Rec Facility is very modern and has great workout center, basketball courts, swimming pool, climbing wall, squash, etc. The student body is very in-shape overall and intramurals are popular.</p>

<p>“Vanderbilt also has D-1 sports which definitely add tremendously to the schools spirit on campus. The football program historically struggles but the program is on the rise. Most of the fun comes from the tailgating (lots of food and socializing before the game). Some people are very traditional and dress up shirt/tie while the girls wear sundresses. Other people dress informally and covering themselves in black/gold paint. Basketball games at Memorial are amazing. The student section gets packed and people will be jumping up and down and whatnot….It’s hard to describe the excitement and incredible atmosphere of the games (try searching YouTube). The baseball team was ranked #1 in the country for most of last year and we have some great recruits coming in. All the sports venues are very centralized on campus and a quick walk from the dorms and the games are all free for students (just show them your Vandy Card).</p>

<p>“Food is pretty good on campus. Quiznos is on the meal plan and I like CT West a lot. The Pub and Rand are also decent. Vanderbilt also has a “Taste of Nashville” program where you can use your rollover money at off-campus locations – such as PapaJohns, Chili’s, RolyPoly Sandwiches, Bruegger’s Bagels, Noshville. Some late night places on the card are Wendy’s (open til 4am) and Café Coco (an alternative style coffee shop – they have burgers/fries and are open 24 hours). Other good coffee shops include JJ’s (has sort of a philosophy sort of vibe with lots of cool couches/tables) and Fido is pretty cool hangout in Hillsboro village.</p>

<p>“My classes at Vandy have been great. Most of the classes are small and teachers are very helpful with office hours. Some classes are rigorous so make sure you time-manage well. Despite stereotypes of the school, the students here are some of the most down-to-earth people I have ever met. The vast majority of the students are really friendly – people hold doors and were just simply raised properly. People would rather be your friend than beat you on a test. Vanderbilt is probably the furthest you can get from a cut throat atmosphere. Community Service is also huge here (esp. with Alternative Spring Break Programs). There also tons of clubs, publications, radio station, etc.</p>

<p>“In short, great academics + great people + great social scene + beautiful campus = Vandy.”</p>

<p>hawkette-- thank you for taking the time to quote so extensively, it's exactly what I wanted. :D</p>

<p>I wish that someone else had a post like that for Emory too, but it's nice to have at least one side fully illustrated.</p>

<p>Emory has a different vibe for several reasons. One major one is the lack of DI sports. I happen to think a strong athletic program changes the feel of a college- for the better, in my opinion, but others will disagree. Emory has a higher percentage of northeasterners. Again, not a plus to me. I live in Nashville and my daughter is a Vandy grad student. She feels the strong Greek scene at Vandy would not have appealed to her as an undergrad. Others are looking for that. We both find Nashville a friendly, fun city and I think it would be a great place to be as an undergrad. I go to Vandy basketball games, and I sure haven't seen a lot of Gucci bags......</p>