Looking at the most conservative colleges on Niche, these are some schools you might want to consider:
- Cedarville (OH…if you’re open to Miami…) has about 3500 undergrads.
- High Point (NC) has about 4900 undergrads. It does not have the academic reputation of William & Mary, but there is a conservative thread through the university and its families seem very happy with the results they get.
- Campbell (NC): has about 3100 undergrads and I’ve heard that it has a good reputation in North Carolina (conservative but solid academically).
- U. of Scranton (PA ): has about 3800 undergrads, and though Jesuit institutions tend to be more progressive, this one is ranked #67 of 1607 among the most conservative universities.
ETA:
Two other schools you might want to consider are:
-
Anderson (SC): has about 3200 undergrads and isn’t far from North Carolina (i.e. desire to be neighboring Virginia)
-
Franciscan U. of Steubenville (OH): has about 2600 undergrads