I have a 2021 as well, so just going through the process, more experienced posters will probably have better advice!
I believe most coaches have an idea of what will pass muster with the Admissions Office, and so will not submit any candidates they feel arenât close to that schoolâs standards. They get a certain number of prereads so donât want to waste a spot (even for a preread) on a kid they are pretty sure is an academic nonstarter.
So, first thing â do the coaches have all your daughterâs academic info (unofficial transcript, grades this year so far etc)?
Then, have they offered her a preread? NESCACs start prereads on July 1, but they can let a player know that they are offering a preread now. (Some schools may be on a faster timeline, some slower, but NESCACs are offering prereads now, at least in my sonâs sport). If your daughter gets a preread, that is really good information to have, it confirms she is in fact one of the top recruits. (My son was told he was a âtop recruitâ too, but when he pressed the coach as to whether the coach would be offering a preread he got the answer that due to the COVID uncertainty the coach wasnât deciding who was getting a preread until July. That may or may not (more likely) be true; but it is good info to have. It tells my son he is in fact not one of the top 10 or 20 recruits the coach is considering).
If the player passes the preread with the Admissions office, AND is made an offer from the coach, then it is extremely likely your daughter will be admitted. From the pool of kids the AO has approved, the coach can pick his top recruits, and those given spots generally are admitted. So yes, once the AO has weighed in, then the coachâs support makes a great deal of difference. But make sure the coach is offering a spot, and not offering soft support.
As for the ACT, given that so many schools have gone TO, for the TO school your daughter just wouldnât submit the score. For the school that still requires board scores youâll have to ask the coach what to do in that case. I.e. âCoach, I took the ACT to get a benchmark at the end of sophomore year, expecting to practice and retake it, but all the tests are cancelled this Spring, if I canât take it again, what should I do/whatâs the effect on my recruitingâ
Do you have access to Naviance? If you look at scattergrams you can see some outliers, kids with surprisingly low gpas or test scores getting into schools like Williams or Harvard (schools with low admit rates). Those might be recruited athletes.
Finally, you may not need this caution, but others might â just because a coach is an excellent recruiter and comes on really strong, it does not necessarily mean that your player is in the top 5 recruits, unless the coach actually says that. Saying âyou are a top recruitâ can mean you are, or can mean you are one of 50 and the coach is just one of those that comes on strong. My sonâs experienced both kinds of coaches, and a quiet coach, one who doesnât send handwritten letters or be in close touch can actually be one where your student is at the top of his list. And, unfortunately, the reverse is true too â a really enthusiastic coach can have your student not at the top of their list. At this point, in my opinion, it isnât a bad thing to push coaches for more clarity so your player knows where they stand.