A Pledge to End Fraternity Hazing- From the President of Cornell

<p>"IN February, a 19-year-old Cornell sophomore died in a fraternity house while participating in a hazing episode that included mock kidnapping, ritualized humiliation and coerced drinking. While the case is still in the courts, the fraternity chapter has been disbanded and those indicted in connection with the death are no longer enrolled here.</p>

<p>This tragedy convinced me that it was time — long past time — to remedy practices of the fraternity system that continue to foster hazing, which has persisted at Cornell, as on college campuses across the country, in violation of state law and university policy.</p>

<p>Yesterday, I directed student leaders of Cornell’s Greek chapters to develop a system of member recruitment and initiation that does not involve “pledging” — the performance of demeaning or dangerous acts as a condition of membership. While fraternity and sorority chapters will be invited to suggest alternatives for inducting new members, I will not approve proposals that directly or indirectly encourage hazing and other risky behavior. National fraternities and sororities should end pledging across all campuses; Cornell students can help lead the way.</p>

<p>Why not ban fraternities and sororities altogether, as some universities have done? Over a quarter of Cornell undergraduates (3,822 of 13,935 students) are involved in fraternities or sororities. The Greek system is part of our university’s history and culture, and we should maintain it because at its best, it can foster friendship, community service and leadership.</p>

<p>Hazing has been formally prohibited at Cornell since 1980 and a crime under New York State law since 1983. But it continues under the guise of pledging, often perpetuated through traditions handed down over generations. Although pledging is explained away as a period of time during which pre-initiates (“pledges”) devote themselves to learning the information necessary to become full members, in reality, it is often the vehicle for demeaning activities that cause psychological harm and physical danger.</p>

<p>About 2,000 alcohol-related deaths occur each year among American college students. Alcohol or drug abuse is a factor in more than a half-million injuries each year — and also in sexual and other assaults, unsafe sex, poor academic performance and many other problems.</p>

<p>At Cornell, high-risk drinking and drug use are two to three times more prevalent among fraternity and sorority members than elsewhere in the student population. During the last 10 years, nearly 60 percent of fraternity and sorority chapters on our campus have been found responsible for activities that are considered hazing under the Cornell code of conduct.</p>

<p>Why would bright young people subject themselves to dangerous humiliation? Multiple factors are at play: the need of emerging adults to separate from family, forge their own identities and be accepted in a group; obedience to authority (in this case, older students); the ineffectiveness of laws and other constraints on group behavior; and organizational traditions that perpetuate hazardous activities.</p>

<p>Alcohol makes it easier for members to subject recruits to physical and mental abuse without feeling remorse and to excuse bad behavior on the grounds of intoxication. It provides a social lubricant, but it impairs the judgment of those being hazed and lowers their ability to resist.</p>

<p>Even more distressing, although 55 percent of college students involved in clubs, teams and organizations experience hazing, the vast majority of them do not identify the events as hazing. Of those who do, 95 percent do not report the events to campus officials.</p>

<p>Doctors, nurses and other student-health professionals have tried to address high-risk drinking and hazing through individual counseling, a medical amnesty process that reduces barriers to calling for help in alcohol emergencies, and educational programs. But the problem has persisted.</p>

<p>There are signs of progress. Jim Yong Kim, president of Dartmouth, has helped organize a multi-campus approach to identifying the most effective strategies against high-risk drinking. The National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism has established a college presidents’ advisory group to develop and share approaches to this problem.</p>

<p>There is a pressing need for better ways to bring students together in socially productive, enjoyable and memorable ways. At Cornell, acceptable alternatives to the pledge process must be completely free of personal degradation, disrespect or harassment in any form. One example is Sigma Phi Epsilon’s “Balanced Man Program,” which replaces the traditional pledging period with a continuing emphasis on community service and personal development.</p>

<p>We need to face the facts about the role of fraternities and sororities in hazing and high-risk drinking. Pledging — and the humiliation and bullying that go with it — can no longer be the price of entry.</p>

<p>David J. Skorton, a cardiologist, is the president of Cornell University."</p>

<p><a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2011/08/24/opinion/a-pledge-to-end-fraternity-hazing.html?hp%5B/url%5D"&gt;http://www.nytimes.com/2011/08/24/opinion/a-pledge-to-end-fraternity-hazing.html?hp&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p>

<p>Isn't about time that parents think long and hard about how they overlook or dismiss so many negative incidents associated with frats, that, too often these days, should no longer be ignored? Does saying "kids will drink", and "no one has to join a frat" mean that we should overlook abusive behavior, just because it happens on a college campus? I don't think so.......</p>

<p>Amen to that!</p>

<p>Neither I nor my family or friends have been Greek, so I’m curious: Despite all of the attempts to ban hazing, it persists. Greeks obviously consider hazing to be central to Greek-dom. Why?</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Change has got to originate from within the organizations in order to be effective.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Why not ban fraternities altogether? Here’s a hint: Because we lack the courage and refuse to look at the facts … despite listing them in this letter:</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>One could hope that a successful multi-million dollar lawsuit might finally bring action as opposed to hollow rhetoric!</p>

<p>Or one could hope that when our country will remember 9/11/2001 and express its indignation, we could also look at the cumulative impact of about 2,000 alcohol-related deaths among American college students and half-million injuries each year. That is 20,000 deaths and 5 million injuries in the same ten years!</p>

<p>I’ve often thought that fraternities and sororities attract those who are attracted to high-risk drinking and drug use. All they do, really, is provide the venue. But data indicate that getting rid of “venues” can make a huge difference in rates of high-risk drinking and drugging. </p>

<p>The data on frat/sorority drinking has been very clear for a long time. (And, yes, I know folks are sorority sisters for life, and deliver hot meals to the homeless, and fraternity brothers sing Christmas carols to the bedridden.)</p>

<p>Why not ban secrecy among all official campus organizations? Require them to publish the details of their recruitment procedures, and punish them if they deviate from them.</p>

<p>My alma mater, to its credit, abolished fraternities in the 60s. At the time, many of the fraternities (some of which were the founding chapters in the 1800s) were almost as powerful as the college itself, and it was great struggle. One or two of the fraternities have survived as secret societies - membership in them as an undergraduate can subject the student to automatic expulsion. (There was, and is, still plenty of drinking and drugging.)</p>

<p>"Greeks obviously consider hazing to be central to Greek-dom. Why? "</p>

<p>do they all? When we were at RPI accepted students, we got the impression some of the sororities at least were mostly service oriented, and not drinking focused. DD (to our great surprise, shes always been kind of shy and a super nerd) indicated an interest in possibly pledging. We would of course want her to have nothing to do with typical frat culture as we have seen it described. RPI an outlier?</p>

<p>The problem isn’t hazing. It’s fraternities.</p>

<p>Notice we don’t have these deaths and other problems in ROTCs, SMCs, military academies or the military…</p>

<p>Get rid of fraternities, problem solved…</p>

<p>"Greeks obviously consider hazing to be central to Greek-dom. Why? "</p>

<p>No, they don’t. Some chapters don’t. I was never hazed and neither was my husband - both of us were members of large national groups. We wouldn’t have put up with such stupidity. No paddling, no enforced drinking, no “humiliation.” Nothing of the sort. Pledges were not second-class status who had to do things to prove their worthiness - they were just, well, newer members, akin to freshmen on a college campus. </p>

<p>As for recruitment practices - I’m afraid you’ll find that the recruitment practices are rather like elite college admissions - there’s a big holistic component involved. It’s rather like asking someone to spell out the process by which they became friends with these girls in the dorm but not those girls. At the end of the day, it’s who you like and click with. I don’t see what recruitment practices has to do with the hazing issue anyway.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>BBD - I am not a drinker (I drank maybe 5 times in college, tops). Neither is my husband. No problems whatsoever enjoying the Greek system. Yes, many drank in college - just like the non-Greeks drank at their parties. It depends on local culture. Animal House is not a documentary.</p>

<p>

What about Revenge of the Nerds?</p>

<p>Is this event and the response to it new? I remember these topics of hazing and frats from my time in college in the 80’s. Drinking at this age is a problem, and I wonder how many non-college students die from alcohol related deaths during the same age range? </p>

<p>To me, the college is not the problem, but it has to be part of the solution. I don’t know what the solution is, honestly. And I have concerns that the more restrictive a rule is, the more underground or secretive drinking will be. Even more problems with that. </p>

<p>It is a tough issue!</p>

<p>Oh, and Revenge of the Nerds, #1 definately documentary- the rest are fiction! LOL</p>

<p>Let’s ask the question differently. Which colleges don’t have problems (or have fewer problems) with underage drinking in general, and what policies / programs do they have in place to enable that? Which colleges (who have Greek systems) seem to have less party-hardy Greek chapters? (And don’t all be smart-alecks and give me BYU and religious Christian colleges)</p>

<p>The cynic in me says that some places may be less drinking-culture oriented – but then it’s just pot instead, which to me says the same thing.</p>

<p>“The cynic in me says that some places may be less drinking-culture oriented – but then it’s just pot instead, which to me says the same thing”</p>

<p>our strong impression is that RPI is less drinking culture oriented, and that the drugs of choice are stimulants (we have been warned kids with prescription ADHD meds must keep them under lock and key). I very much doubt that that particular campus culture is easily replicated.</p>

<p>I hesitate to comment on frats and hazing because I just can never wrap my little mind around why anyone would go through it voluntarily.</p>

<p>I do, however, think there is something in community service. If you want recruits (if you can’t call them pledges) to prove themselves, how about the frat requiring mandatory 8 hour shifts every weekend at a soup kitchen or Habitat build?</p>

<p>?? There are plenty of Greek systems that already require some kind of mandatory service component during the pledging period, and require X amount of service over the course of the year to retain membership in good standing. Frankly, I don’t think that makes much of a difference – the same student can volunteer at the soup kitchen during the day and party like a rock star at night – requiring more service doesn’t change that. </p>

<p>But more importantly, getting rid of hazing means getting rid of the mentality that newer members have to jump through hoops for older members’ amusement. Or, put a different way, they can jump through hoops but they have to be “mild,” light-hearted ones. For example, I’ve heard that at Dartmouth they build bonfires and the newest class comes in and the upperclassmen call them “worst class ever” but it’s all taken in a light-hearted spirit. In essence, that’s a tradition designed to welcome you to something. Is that hazing?</p>

<p>I just have never been able to figure out why a person would want to be life long friends with someone who was a jerk to you on purpose - whether it’s putting you in a life threatening situation or calling you names. D’s cheer coach looked the other way last year when the seniors mildly hazed the freshman cheerleaders. D thought those girls were jerks and disliked them the whole year, and it even made me dislike their mothers.</p>

<p>“I just have never been able to figure out why a person would want to be life long friends with someone who was a jerk to you on purpose - whether it’s putting you in a life threatening situation or calling you names.”</p>

<p>WELL SAID!!</p>