Am I OVERTHINKING the essay topics I want to write about? :(

For the essay prompts, I’m mostly leaning toward #1 (personal background/identity/Interest/Special Talent) and # 5 (transition from childhood to adult). I came up with ideas I thought that I could passionately write about…but after going through other threads and helpful sites that gave writing tips, I feel that all the topics I chose are too cliche, unoriginal, and could bore the college admissions officer. These are the topics:

For Prompt #1

  • The young Chinese American girl that experienced the ‘best of both worlds’; lived in city and then moved to countryside (where I am now); expressing both cultures in an environment that only expressed one.
  • Artistic Development; loved drawing as a child, but was discouraged to pursue hobby further than needed; grades were ‘more important’ and drawing was ‘waste of time’; I decided that drawing was my gift and could express what I could not with words.
  • Imagination (Escape From Reality Me only To Find A True self); I always have a vivid mind so when troubles come up in life, I created heroines in other worlds that represented the me I wanted to be (through writing and drawing); however, I wanted to be like the heroine in real life and so my imagination and creativity pushed me to move forward.

For Prompt #5

  • Sister Leaves For College; was the only child left in the house, felt a little lonely and more pressure was put on academics, chores, and responsibilities to family; learned to become more independent and responsible.
  • Moved to the 'Boro when I was 11; matured in an unfamiliar environment that I at first despised but learned to cope with for the sake of father’s situation; now I find good memories in the small country town that shaped me from an incoming middle-school student to a graduating high-school senior.

Being Asian is not easy, but I’m sure there are a ton of essays out there that want to touch this tempting topic! Also, I feel like drawing is such a simple hobby–I didn’t dance my way to the stage, earned a black belt, or raised horses for a passion. Moving to another city also may be cliche as well and I wonder if my ‘Imagination’ topic will seem strange to admission officers. I’ll keep thinking for more ideas but PLEASE LET ME KNOW WHAT YOU THINK about the ones I already have and if there is an interesting one I should take a shot at writing for! Thank you!

:slight_smile:

Any of these essays has the potential to be boring but also potential to be very interesting! It doesn’t matter how cliched the general topic is if you can 1. Include enough details to make the essay specific to you and 2. Come to a conclusion that isn’t trite or generic. Those things are just harder to achieve when the topic is cliched, which is why it’s better to stay away from certain topics. But in particular, I’ve read many essays about a move from one country to another, but never from city to country, so that could be very interesting.

The Imagination essay is the most interesting one in my opinion.

Don’t try to fit your essay into a topic; write your essay from the bottom of your heart, then fit a prompt into your essay.

As a writer, I’d love to read this essay. :stuck_out_tongue: You could definitely start out very uniquely…like describing a brief scene from one of these heroines’ adventures.

"A thick silence settles over the city block as the gathered crowd watches in horror. Squirrel Girl lies prone on the pavement, felled by a punch from her arch-nemesis, Old Man Winter. A finger twitches, briefly. Old Man Winter throws back his head and laughs, a chilling laugh, cold like ice. “You’ve bested me before, Squirrel Girl, but now it is I who have the upper hand!”

Will she get up? Can the day still be saved?

(Hint: yes, and yes.)

Squirrel Girl always gets up, and the day can always be saved. That’s because Squirrel Girl is fictional – a braver and more powerful version of me, created in my daydreams in times of trouble. But Squirrel Girl isn’t just a figment of my imagination…"