Amherst College vs University of Chicago vs Pomona College

Feeling extremely fortunate to have been accepted to Amherst + UChicago (Pomona I was wait-listed). In the case of Pomona, i’m debating whether or not to state that I would go to the school if offered admission in my continued letter of interest. I understand that there’s a large chance I won’t get into Pomona via the wait-list, but in case I do I’d really appreciate some insight into the school. I am extremely conflicted on where to attend.

Short bio:
I’m an international student interested in majoring in Economics, and potentially double majoring in Public Policy. However i’m extremely excited about studying liberal arts as I have a wide range of academic interests (also really into chemistry, IR, human geography, and I would love to explore subjects such as philosophy + CS through electives). I’m also very interested in urban studies/policy which really draws me towards UChicago because of their Urban labs initiative + Urban education institute. Besides academics, i’m into dance (mainly Ballet + contemporary) + music and I hope to further pursue these hobbies at university.

If you have researched about the any of the schools or are an alum/ currently enrolled student, please feel free to give me your 2 cents on the following:

Location: Internship opportunities, Job opportunities,
Academics: Strongest and weakest departments, degrees of competition or collaboration, research opportunities, faculty involvement
Social: general atmosphere, fixed hierarchy/fluidity, time to pursue EC’s and socialize amidst the worklad
Future preparation: Job placement, name recognition

Some of my current thoughts:

  • I’m extremely indecisive on whether I would prefer UChicago’s core as opposed to Amherst’s flexible curriculum with no requirements. UChicago’s core sounds absolutely fantastic to me but i’m also worried that it might restrict my ability to pursue certain subjects that I would be able to at Amherst.
  • I do think I would work well in a small LAC - forging close relationships with the professors, having a more intimate/engaging work environment etc, but I also feel like UChicago may offer a large variety of research opportunities a small LAC wouldn't be able to, especially those pertaining to urban policy.
  • One thing i'm slightly worried about at Amherst is the social divide between athletes and non-athletes (especially seeing as the small school of 1800ish has about 70% athletes) I've heard some people say it's not that bad and others say it's quite bad.
  • I've generally heard that Amherst has a much bigger pull in the job market than Pomona due to having a larger alumni connection (since the school is older). After I graduate, I plan on working in the U.S (hopefully..) before going to grad school, so UChicago's international reputation isn't as huge of a + to me. Being an international student however, I do feel my perception on all three school's reputation may be a bit skewed, so any insight into this would be greatly appreciated.
  • Pomona's + Amherst's job internships sound amazing and it seems the school's have an excess of opportunities in this area. Does anybody know what it's like at UChicago? especially since it's a bigger school etc.
  • Pomona seems to be the school that is most invested in the arts (dance, music etc) and their dance program seems really really great.
  • I'm drawn much more to Pomona's consortium than Amherst's as it seems to be a lot more integrated. Most Amherst students i've spoken to haven't ventured to the other colleges and at Pomona the specializations of the colleges seems much more diverse - HMC CS/Sciences, CMC Econ/Gov, etc

Hey, current Amherst student here.

First, to clarify something: 70% of Amherst students play a sport in some way–but only about 30% are on a varsity team. The other 40% play a club or intramural sport (practice 1-2 times a week, with no pressure. Everyone who wants to join must be accepted to these teams, which are much more casual). Think of Amherst as a campus with many athletic people, but only about 30% hardcore “athletes.”

Your questions:

Location: Internship opportunities, Job opportunities. Almost every student does an internship every summer. Amherst has a tight-knit alumni network that posts jobs for students, summer and full-time. The career center fosters relationships with both industrial giants and local businesses. You’ll have no trouble finding an internship. However, it will likely not be local–Amherst is a rural school. Your summer internship/full-time job will probably be in Boston, New York, Philadelphia, etc.
Academics: Poli sci is one of our strongest departments and most popular majors. Research opportunities ABOUND–definitely a big difference from UChi. Here there are no grad students, so professors do all their research with undergrads. Funding for research is everywhere, too. Small classes, close prof relationships (Amherst even pays for students to go out to dinner with professors!).
Social: general atmosphere, fixed hierarchy/fluidity, time to pursue EC’s and socialize amidst the workload. Amherst has a place for everyone; our school is extremely diverse. I think that there is slightly too much work here, but most students are able to balance work/social events/ECs. Keep in mind that if you killed yourself in HS (which you likely did if you got into Amherst) you do not have to do that here–one or two ECs is fine…Amherst wants you to have a social life.
Future preparation: Job placement, name recognition. Excellent. Almost everyone gets a job straight out of Amherst, and prestigious ones, too.

Edit: Should mention that I also chose between UChi and Amherst. I chose Amherst because
a) didn’t want to live in Chicago
b) UChi is GIGANTIC compared to Amherst, and is a Uni, not a college
c) didn’t want to have to take a core curriculum

The U of C campus is Ok but the surrounding area is very sketchy. The school keeps this hushed up but you can see the police reports if you look. Academically they are equal. NU is on the gold coast but U of C is in a far worse location.

@theviolethour Thanks so much, it’s reassuring to know that Amherst does a great job in setting up its students with internships + jobs.

Do you ever find it a bit isolating in Amherst? I know there’s UMASS around the corner but from what I’ve read, Amherst students don’t tend to mingle there too often? (With maybe a few exceptions).