<p>There is one truth I have seen over the last eight years in college athletics - every recruiting class gets faster and stronger. In some sports/conferences the increase is so rapid that it is stunning. I have heard fenwaysouth often advise “go where you can play”. I would advise you to factor that in also. </p>
<p>You mention that you have a slim chance of receiving an athletic scholarship which (I think) implies you are not at the top of this recruiting class. Can you improve enough next year to become stronger than most of the current class and be stronger than the next recruiting class? Also, will you travel to the conference championships with school 2 and do you have a chance of going to NCAAs with school 2? A lot of athletes get left home, if not the first year then in later years when the younger classes come in stronger. This isn’t a reason to not go to school 2, it is just another thing to consider. Who are you and will you be okay with your playing time/contribution either way? Where would you feel better about your impact on the team?</p>
<p>It is very mature of you to consider money and you are the only one who can decide what impact that has on your decision, it’s great your parents are supportive either way. If the true cost difference is a couple thousand dollars then that is not a lot in the world of tuition but if it is a couple thousand dollars PLUS a lot of loans for you that is a significant decision. </p>
<p>Honestly…my opinion is it is okay to choose a school for the amazing athletic experience (as long as they are both sound academically). Everyone has to choose a school for some reason and it is natural to choose a school based on your interests and passions. Yes, be sure you will be happy there if you can’t play but beyond that realize your priorities and give yourself permission to choose based on those. Most of the student athletes I know can’t go abroad or take advantage of research opportunities anyway because they have such an huge commitment to their sport. Being a college athlete is a very intense experience and will be different than the non-athletic experience in so many ways. Choose where you think you will be most satisfied and challenged across the board and then don’t look back. It sounds like you will be happy at either school - so win-win!</p>