Carnegie Mellon or Northeastern for Pre-Med?

Disclaimer: this’ll be a long post. Well, maybe not. I have no idea what the average length of posts are here :P.

A lot of people looked at me like I was crazy when I asked this question. “The hell are you doing still debating? It’s obviously Carnegie Mellon - think of the prestige!” Maybe I’m wrong, but I’m fairly certain that the brand of clothing one wears says nothing about their character. However, I will concede that Carnegie Mellon probably earned that level of renown through the quality of their education.

First, some basic info: I’m currently enrolled in Dietrich as an Econ major, which I’m planning to transfer out of after first semester (if I go). At Northeastern, I’m listed as a Biochem major, which I don’t plan to change.

The main thing I’m juggling right now is the quality of said education vs. the availability of out-of-school options. From what I’ve gathered from various pre-health information sessions, medical schools are placing an enormous emphasis on internships, shadowing, etc. as opposed to the traditional GPA and MCAT score package. At Carnegie Mellon, I was told by the Director of Pre-Health that the best solution to this would be to search for internships, largely on my own, and eventually take a gap year and apply for Teach for America or Peace Corps. Meanwhile, in Northeastern, I was told that the Co-Op program would supplant the traditional gap year (if desired) and that they would assist me in finding an ideal spot at a company or hospital. Furthermore, I believe that the various affiliated companies and hospitals are more likely to take in students from Northeastern, thanks to their reputation as a solid sender of students (for lack of a better phrase). So, in the end I’m not really competing with other schools but instead just within Northeastern.

Another smaller issue (but still very important nonetheless) is tuition. I have received no financial aid from Carnegie Mellon. I have received the Dean’s Scholarship for Northeastern. While my parents insist that they can pay full tuition for Carnegie Mellon, I know for a fact they’ll be suffering for it and I don’t want to have that bearing on my conscience (love, and all that jazz). Adding to the fact that they won’t have to pay for the Co-Op semesters (and I’ll likely be making some decent money during those 6 months) and it’s a really hard sell for me. My parents really want me to take the higher-ranked college, but I see equal (in a different form) opportunity and a cheaper cost at Northeastern. What do you guys recommend I do?

http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/pre-med-topics/1484178-if-you-are-in-high-school-please-read-this-before-posting-p1.html

I don’t really know anything about those two schools. Since you’re posting this here instead of http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/carnegie-mellon-university/ or http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/northeastern-university/ I’ll give you the best advice I can which is that Brown is the best place to be a pre med: http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/brown-university/1284648-brown-is-the-best-place-to-be-a-pre-med-p1.html

Why do you think Carnegie Mellon is so prestigious? AFAIK, CM and Northeastern are peers.

Look at the AMCAS data on acceptances vs. GPA and MCAT scores. Nothing has changed, GPA/MCAT is very very important.

@plumazul is right, what you’re probably misunderstanding OP is that with the growing numbers of applicants, a good GPA/MCAT is no longer enough to get in to medical school. So it’s not that those things are important instead of GPA/MCAT, it’s that those things are important on top of a great GPA/MCAT.