Choosing a computer for college? Mac or PC?

<p>The reasons i love Linux:</p>

<p>No viruses...no security problems ever... you will never lose any assignments or anything
Linux is a technology that improves IT agility to meet many people's demands
It's VERY Cheap ;)
Flexibility (able to run with other systems)
Very powerful almost or as good as Unix
It keeps pace with technology more than most other systems for example a new Windows operating system will come out ever like 5 years for Microsoft and with Linux it just keeps up with technology.
Linux is Network-friendly
Very good with having many applications running at the same time that it doesn't really slow down your performance
It's an open system
Very reliable...doesn't screw you over
Woks well with even old school equipment...you don't need like 1 million GB of memory to run it...
You can make it work however you want it to your perfection....(though it will take a while)
And finally, i like it because unlike the billions of other people in the world,..... I actually know how to use it..</p>

<p>I just wrote why i liked it...I didn't really feel like explaining the differneces...</p>

<p>Firstly, the 5% Mac market share statistic is only based on Q1 2007 sales in the US from a Gartner report released a month or so ago. The same report also shows that Mac's worldwide market share is still about 2.4%--based on FY 2006 sales. Domestic (US) market share for that same time period was a little above 4%. Of course, Apple now dominates the laptop market, pulling about 15% for the last three quarters.</p>

<p>The crux of the biscuit? Windows is still the dominant player. However, industry analysts have noted that Parallels and Boot Camp, coupled with tepid consumer and corporate response to Windows Vista may shuffle the deck a little bit. Still, it's yet to be seen if that means a major platform shift is imminent; only time will tell.</p>

<p>As far as Linux goes, I'm a huge supporter of Ubuntu. After getting fed up with XP last year, I switched full time to Linux. I sampled a few flavors (including SuSE and Fedora Core) but ultimately picked Ubuntu. Install is exceptionally straightforward, the Gnome desktop environment is very friendly, and everything about the distro (the particular "version" or "flavor" of Linux, for those of you not familiar) was geared towards the first-time Linux user. I would not hesitate to recommend it to anyone. Ubuntu comes prepackaged with all of the software you'll need, and anything else you might want is easily acquired using its well-designed package manager. Ubuntu also pre-installs a bunch of networking tools to make it really easy for first time users to get up and running, even on a wireless network.</p>

<p>All in all, I was very happy with Ubuntu. However, what brought me back to the Windows world was Windows Vista. I've been using it exclusively since Beta 2, and I've had very few problems. The feature set is fantastic, and it's far more stable than XP ever was. It's important to remember also that 1) Windows Vista Search was introduced at PDC 2003, while Spotlight was implemented in MacOS X in mid-2004, and 2) Windows Vista has the "Previous Versions" feature implemented by default--though it's been a feature since XP SP2/Server 2003--which works the same as Apple's Time Machine, only without the goofy interface.</p>

<p>So yes, Vista did copy some features from MacOS (like transparency, etc.), but it wasn't exclusively Redmond "starting their photocopiers," as Steve Jobs said last year. There's a lot to like in Windows Vista--enough for the boys in Cupertino to get just as jealous about it as most Windows users are of the Mac.</p>

<p>In Summary:
1) Windows is dominant, and Vista is actually quite good.
2) There's a lot to like about the Mac, but it's not for everyone, and a lot of its benefits are overstated by its fans.
3) Linux is quickly becoming a viable alternative on the desktop. It's not that hard to use, and it's worth a look if you're on the adventurous side.
4) If you want to stay with Windows for now, but see what open source and Linux have to offer, download the Open CD (<a href="http://www.theopencd.org/%5B/url%5D"&gt;http://www.theopencd.org/&lt;/a&gt;) and try out some open source apps!</p>

<p>has anyone bothered to mention the right-click button? i've been considering getting a mac for college but i decided i will miss the right click button terribly.</p>

<p>Buy a separate mouse. A wireless mini-mouse is great for laptops. OS X does support right-clicking, but it's usually accessed by holding down the Command button while left-clicking.</p>

<p>Still, even though I've considered buying a MacBook Pro and using Boot Camp to dual boot with Vista, not having a right mouse button on the touchpad has been one of the things that's held me back. It's understandable.</p>

<p>Haha I love how people are bringing linux into this discussion. </p>

<p>If you have been using windows for your whole life, and have had no beef with it, I would suggest to continue using it. Despite its shortcomings, its a decent OS when configured correctly. i woudlnt suggest vista though, not until sevice pack 1 comes out. there are just way too many bugs in vista right now. I got it from my school and tried it for free, I hated it. many of my applications would not work, and thats stupid allow/deny window just ****es me off. </p>

<p>I dont think I would recommend Mac's unless the only purpose of your computer is to surf the web, movies, music, pictures and other basic tasks. If you want to play games, dont even think about it. Other less popular programs are not ported to Mac as well. I feel that the OS is very limited in its use. I also believe the premium on the hardware is too expensive. </p>

<p>Now I see that a lot of people are advocating linux on this thread. I myself am a full time ubuntu user. while linux does have many many advantages over other operating systems. I would be hesitant to recommend it to the general public. Ideally, it would be nice if a lot of people switched to linux, but currently, i still believe its not user-friendly enough to be brought into the mainstream. I will say though, that ubuntu is probably the easiest to use. I started with fedora core 6 as my first distribution, and i had many problems that i had to fix, and using the command line was very daunting at first. If you know a bit about how computers work and are willing to troubleshoot some problems, i would highly recommend ubuntu linux, ive have been using it for a half year and i dont miss windows one bit. However, if you are so unsure about your OS where you need to ask people on a forum for suggestions, i would stay away from it, its probably not your cup of tea.</p>

<p>
[QUOTE]
has anyone bothered to mention the right-click button? i've been considering getting a mac for college but i decided i will miss the right click button terribly.

[/QUOTE]
</p>

<p>
[QUOTE]
Still, even though I've considered buying a MacBook Pro and using Boot Camp to dual boot with Vista, not having a right mouse button on the touchpad has been one of the things that's held me back. It's understandable.

[/QUOTE]
</p>

<p>The touchpads sense when there are two fingers touching. Two fingers touching + click = right click. Also, for scrolling, just put two fingers down and move them up, down, or side to side.
Not sure if Apple added two finger clicking in vista yet though.</p>

<p>So if I'm going to be concentrating in Political Science and Sociology most likey......what would be the best PC? I've never really used Macs and don't know if I need some of those features it comes with. I mean I don't have an Ipod anymore and I doubt I'll be creating too many DVDs....how ever the speed of the system is very appealing to me.</p>

<p>Best is relative to what you want to do? Play games? Budget?</p>

<p>ASUS has a new laptop out with HDMI 1.3. It is the first user-upgradeable laptop, so you can upgrade everything including the CPU. I don't rememebr the name but try google.</p>

<p>HP has some nice 17" laptops.</p>

<p>a) desktops aren't just slightly more powerful than laptops. yeah maybe if you're comparing an $1800 laptop to a $1100 desktop.</p>

<p>b)</p>

<p>"A Mac is generally known for being a creative powerhouse. It's a fantastic OS for anyone in a creative field(i.e.: Music, Video, Art)"</p>

<p>No. PCs are just as good as Macs for that kind of thing, especially nowadays with affordable Quad-Core CPUs. Try to match up a Mac to the specs of a PC for that kind of PC and it's at least $1000 more expensive. You could easily build another cheap PC for that $1000 and setup a render farm making it even better.</p>

<p>"For me, Windows is a very messy OS. It lacks, should I say, the polish that OS X has. Additionally, there is 0(and I literally mean 0) Viruses for the Mac. While there is thousands and thousands for the PC(none of which can be run on a Mac)."</p>

<p>Lol, 0 viruses for Mac. Of course the viruses are mostly for Windows. Why would a programmer waste his time on 5% of the market?</p>

<p>"With a Mac, you can run both Mac OS X and Windows. This is near impossible to do with a PC(legally). So a Mac is the only computer in the world that can run all of the mainstream OS's."</p>

<p>If Windows sucks so much, why do you want to run it on a Mac?</p>

<p>"I do think you should mention iLife suite. iTunes/iPhoto/iMovie/iDVD/GarageBand all bundled into every Mac for free; the easiest and best photo manager, movie maker, DVD maker, music maker all working together."</p>

<p>hahaha, sorry FCP pro is FAR better than iMovie, and Audacity/Adobe Audition are FAR better than Garageband. Adobe Encore > iDVD. there's a reason apple gives it for "free" ;)</p>

<p>And if you're just talking about the OS argument, then why not mention Linux? Linux is open source. I.e., if you don't like a feature/don't see one, you can edit/write the code yourself.</p>

<p>"I'm just not interested in spending money on aesthetics. (that is what you're paying for with Apple hardware)"</p>

<p>Aesthetics and propriety.</p>

<p>"Generally, a PC is Windows. I clearly mentioned that was the context I was speaking in so Mac vs PC; Mac vs Windows, it's all the same."</p>

<p>PC = Personal Computer, including Macs. But for practical purposes, we can assume PCs are Windows (or Linux) machines.</p>

<p>"Please, Linux? This is a for college thread. Most college students have no idea what Linux is. You have to admit Mac and Windows are the two main players, and the ones worth comparing."</p>

<p>Are you trying to insult the general intelligence of the members of this forum? I'm sure plenty here are CS majors-to-be.</p>

<p>"Yes, Windows XP has tons of viruses that install itself."</p>

<p>Yeah, if you visit all kinds of spammy, pr0n-ridden websites and don't know anything about protecting/managing your computer.</p>

<p>"I will be damed to find a Dell with an iSight/iChat AV built in equivalent. I just really don't see why so many hate Macs here. Mac OS X (and Macs in general) is not that big of a deal... people treat it like it's the devil or something."</p>

<p>You can build your own PC (desktop at least). I've heard of doing so with Macs, but it was only a G4, and very limited parts. With building PCs, you save tons of money and your choice is limited to the entire PC market.</p>

<p>"As for the Apple haters claiming that there is nothing special about an Apple Computer ... You've never owned a Mac, obviously. Apple Computers are designed specifically for Mac OS X. What this means is you get the thing KNOWING that it will work perfectly, and run smoothly. Can you say the same about your Windows Notebook? Not unless Microsoft starts making them, and that ain't going to happen folks."</p>

<p>I have owned a Mac. And I didn't like it. My family has owned several, and I don't like any of them. I know EXACTLY what I'm getting when I know about my Q6600, my GTS8800 640MB, my Seagate 320GB HDD's, etc. I know it will run perfectly and smoothly.</p>

<p>"Again, this is a college board. No-one here is going to need a computer with unlimited access of parts. Even if they did, a Mac Pro would be just as fast(not as advanced in hardware, but just as fast all the same) as any PC you could build, they come with 8 core CPUs now."</p>

<p>For absurd prices. Have you checked the pricing on them? And why wouldn't they need it? Of course not for some random student who doesn't know anything about computers and wants to e-mail and watch DVDs.</p>

<p>"Unless you are a motion picture or animation studio, who needs 8 cores? Who needs unlimited access to parts? Sure, you're locked down to the hardware you get with your Mac, but that hardware will always run well with OS X. So what's the point in upgrading? RAM? There's a door on every Mac that allows this to be very easily upgraded."</p>

<p>Yeah, and I thought my 64MB Geforce3 would be good back in 2002. Now how does it compare? A college computer should be built to last long and be upgradable. 5-6 years. Through college and then some until you have a stable enough job or whatever to finance a new computer.</p>

<p>"When posting, please remember the context of this thread. It's meant toward college students, not l33t ubber animators that need a machine that can render two hour scenes."</p>

<p>They use render farms for that.</p>

<p>"Want to kill yourself trying to get your computer run smoothly? Want to spend hours a month making sure Windows is clean and tidy? Want to loose some brain cells? A PC is for you!"</p>

<p>Haha, losing brain cells. Oh god, please don't make me actually LEARN about how computers work :( It's PATHETIC how many people use computers so often, yet don't even know a thing about them or how they work. And the machines run fine if you actually know what you're doing.</p>

<p>"Mac OS X:</p>

<p>Don't want to have any options for future modification? Don't want to have to think when choosing/setting up your computer? Don't feel like ever having to use your brain at all? Then a Mac is the computer for you.</p>

<p>I'll take a Mac, thanks."</p>

<p>Haha, really speaks to your character.</p>

<p>"What is the mac fanboy's solution? Get an extended warranty and/or take it to the apple store. Maybe I don't want to go to a store every time something goes wrong."</p>

<p>Haha, I know someone who works at an Apple store... the last story I heard there was someone who had a broken PC who didn't realize there were cockroaches dwelling inside the laptop. Really shows the level of computer knowledge XD</p>

<p>"I know a lot of people that own Macs, none of which have any serious problems. I've owned my Mac for 8 months and haven't had a single problem."</p>

<p>No problems? Those who I know who have macs... they don't have any problems... except for the distinct lack of speed for how much money they paid for it.</p>

<p>"Um windows is the most unstable system I've ever seen. XP is a complete failure that should never have been released. How does Microsoft sleep after having released a product that is supposedly perfect when they know damn well that it's not? I used to have a crash about twice a week, sometimes three times. I have had to reinstall windows about a dozen times, and programs crash all the time."</p>

<p>I've never had this problem. Generally speaking, most of these errors are induced by novice users.</p>

<p>I know you'll all probably hate me for bringing this back to OSX vs. Windows, but what is the point of this thread anyway? It doesn't have distinguishable facts that are enough to make a decision with. Why, it seems that there is a peculiar agenda to suggest Mac to everyone. And that might be OK for some random thread, but this is a featured thread, and as such, it should probably be cleaned up to reflect its status.</p>

<p>@awb1989</p>

<p>Finally, some good arguments! Let me refute another of this guy's points:</p>

<p>"I will be damed to find a Dell with an iSight/iChat AV built in equivalent."</p>

<p>Oh, I didn't know that Dell was the only company that made PC's. You see, unlike Macs, PC desktops don't ahve a built in monitor, so that you aren't tied into one piece of equipment even after it becomes obsolete. </p>

<p>Imagine somebody sewing your pants to your shirt. Once your pants rip, you have to throw it away along with your shirt, but with a PC you can replace each part separately for much less money.</p>

<p>For a PC desktop, just buy your own webcam if you want one so much and you have a wide variety to choose from which will work with Windows whereas many webcams don't work for OS X.</p>

<p>For laptops, have you ever even heard of PC manufacturers other than Dell? Just about every Sony and HP laptop has a built-in webcam.</p>

<p>"Um windows is the most unstable system I've ever seen."</p>

<p>No offense, but I think a mac is perfect for you. It's meant for those people who have no clue about how to use a computer. My XP 64-bit machine has no viruses and starts up in under 30 seconds. How is this possible?!?! I don't surf random warez or pr0n sites. I also don't install a EXE file when I visit websites.</p>

<p>If you still think you can get viruses, then do this:
1. When you first get your PC, format the hard drive
2. Create 2 partitions: 1 for windows and 1 for your own data
3. Install everything to the non-windows aprtition
4. If the computer feels slow, then format the non-windows partition</p>

<p>Just to show more clearly what I was talking about earlier with pricing... I'll try comparing a Mac with a similar setup to my PC for pricing comparison.</p>

<p>CPU: It's a Quad-Core 2.4GHz. Closest Mac option is two 2.66GHz Dual-Cores.
RAM: 2GB... but it'll have to be 667MHz instead of 800 (don't you think $299 for a 1GB RAM upgrade is a RIPOFF?).
Hard Drives: Mine has dual 320GB hdd's. Closest I can get here is one 250GB HDD and one 500GB. The 500GB is $329?? Wow... just wow.
GPU: I've got the Geforce GTS8800 640MB. So let's go with the Radeon X1900 XT 512MB (I'm not as familiar with the Radeon cards, so I might be a little off in which card is closest to mine in performance).
No monitor since I didn't buy a monitor with my new PC... I already had one.
One SuperDrive to match my DVD/CD burner with lightscribe. Does the SuperDrive have lightscribe?</p>

<p>Final Price: $3,376. Compare that to around $2500 from ABS (reliable company affiliated with newegg). Or under $2000 if you're building it yourself. Apple rips you off for propriety. I can't imagine ever being asked to pay for $299 to upgrade from 1GB to 2GB of RAM, ESPECIALLY when it's not even 800MHz.</p>

<p>About the graphics card. The 8800GTS is WAY better than that ATI card. The Geforce is DirectX10 while the ATI is Direct X9. Even the new ATI DX10 cards aren't as powerful as the 8800GTS (which isn't even Nvidia's best card).</p>

<p>No offense, but ABS ripped you off as well, but at least your realize it. It's really not that hard to build a computer. If it's your first time, then just wear latex gloves the whole time and don't leave it plugged into the outlet while you build it and you can't mess anything up.</p>

<p>"About the graphics card. The 8800GTS is WAY better than that ATI card. The Geforce is DirectX10 while the ATI is Direct X9. Even the new ATI DX10 cards aren't as powerful as the 8800GTS (which isn't even Nvidia's best card)."</p>

<p>I figured. But I wanted to give Apple the benefit of the doubt by not choosing the $1600 (***) card and thus making the price displacement even larger. And I chose the 8800GTS over the GTX because the increase in performance wasn't worth the extra $300 or whatever it is.</p>

<p>"No offense, but ABS ripped you off as well, but at least your realize it. It's really not that hard to build a computer. If it's your first time, then just wear latex gloves the whole time and don't leave it plugged into the outlet while you build it and you can't mess anything up."</p>

<p>I know. I wanted to build it, but my parents were too apprehensive. So they'd rather pay the extra money for a company to build it. But at least it's not a crappy case like Dell's. They do offer their own cases, but I got an Antec.</p>

<p>@afruff I'm not really going to need it for gaming (I might bring the PS3 with me), but I don't want my laptop to be a slouch. I'm trying to stay under 1,400 I guess. I could probably stretch it a little, but I like UMich's deal on the macbook where I even get a 3-year warranty and it's still at about 1380. I'm not sold on that monitor size tho....it's like 13.3'.</p>

<p>Warranties are a big scam. As long as you're not an idiot and leave your laptop on the ground so your roommate can trip over it, you'll be fine. Although, with a Macbook I might be wrong. They have some overheating problems and could possibly be a fire hazard. Just do some research on the laptop you want to get and make sure there are no problems with it.</p>

<p>Here's my suggestion:
<a href="http://www.amazon.com/Pavilion-DV6575US-Notebook-Processor-Premium/dp/B000RGG5EW%5B/url%5D"&gt;http://www.amazon.com/Pavilion-DV6575US-Notebook-Processor-Premium/dp/B000RGG5EW&lt;/a>
<a href="http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16834147485%5B/url%5D"&gt;http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16834147485&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p>

<p>They're both the same laptop, but I just wanted you to see that it's not normally $1250. It's on sale. You can even watch HD or analog TV on this computer with the included tuner!</p>

<p>Where do you find these deals man? Should I just keep looking on Amazon in the 1300-1500 range? I actually tried out a Macbook today at the apple store and I didn't really like it that much. I liked the PC though, but I'm not looking for one of those. Something about the feel of the keyboard.....I didn't like. So I was looking in other stores at Vaio's, Dells....didn't find HP though.</p>

<p>Well, I first find the laptop at newegg.com since it has a good review system. I also check cnet.com Newegg often has the product for the lowest price, but i still check other retailers like amazon.com</p>

<p>You coulda lso find laptops off of bestbuy and circuit city's website bu then look online for better deals.</p>

<p>I've got a question for our resident computer-chosing expert. I'm not getting a mac because all of the programs I own are for Windows, and using Windows on a Mac voids your warrenty. Furthermore, I use a Mac almost everyday at school and I just prefer Windows.</p>

<p>That being said, I use some high-end 3d software (namely 3d Studio Max and occasionally Maya) which is like a RAM-monger when it comes to rendering. Additionally, I use photoshop, illustrator, indesign, dreamweaver, flash, etc. almost everyday. How much RAM/memory do I need? And does a graphics card have anything to do with this, for the 3d work?</p>

<p>I'm so uninformed.</p>

<p>Get at least 2 GB of ram. I installed blender on my laptop, with 1.2 GB, and it crashes and slows down a lot. </p>

<p>Just don't get an integrated graphics cards and you should be fine.</p>

<p>@golddustwoman</p>

<p>Get AT LEAST 2 GB of RAM. If you get more than 3 GB then you will need a 64-bit operating system like Vista 64-bit or Windows XP x64.</p>

<p>As far as graphics card. Yes, this can drastically alter rendering times. I'm not too keen on graphic rendering, but I think that the Nvidia quadro workstation line of graphics card is better suited to this type of work than the geforce gamer line.</p>