College comparison? UIUC, UW, UCSD, HKUST

Hey members of College Confidential,

I’m currently stuck in the purgatory of choosing where to go for college. As of today, I hold offers from:
University of Washington (Pre-science)
UIUC (Undeclared – General Studies)
UC San Diego (Mathematics-Computer Science)

I also have an offer from an overseas university, which might be slightly unfamiliar to you guys:
Hong Kong University of Science and Technology (conditional—if I finish my IB Diploma with 34 points, CoE)
http://www.topuniversities.com/universities/hong-kong-university-science-technology/undergrad

I’m a US citizen studying in Hong Kong and I’m planning on majoring in Computer Science in college. The original plan was to study in America in a prestigious school, but then I realized that I might have to take out loans to pay for college. Right now, it’s looking at around 40-45k/year for a US school and only around 5k/year for HKUST. I feel that if I study in HKUST, I might not have as good job prospects as I would have in the States. I’m also concerned about losing opportunities that I would have had if I chose to go to stay in Hong Kong instead of going back to the States. However, graduating nearly debt-free is really attractive.

I would be grateful if I could get some input from you guys on the subject (what the choice should be, personal experiences at the school(s), etc.) Thanks a lot!

bump

Can somebody please respond. The answer would help me as well.

I don’t have the most in-depth knowledge on this, but i’ll muster a response:
UW, UIUC, and UCSD are all TOP-notch Computer Science programs. Choosing between those you should look at cost, school environment, and what location you would want a career at. Although with a degree from any you could easily get a cs job anywhere. I’m not sure how PreScience/Undeclared/MathCS as a freshman effects getting into CS though.

As for the Hong Kong university, yes there is a bigger obstacle in getting a job if the degree is from a foreign university. UW/UIUC/UCSD will hold much more weight and probably teach you a lot more. But also it comes down to what you eventually know and personal projects you have on GitHub and such.

40k/year is a huge sum, especially when there’s a 5k/year offer. No one can decide that for you. If you graduate in the US and work in silicon valley though, you can potentially be making $120k/yr after 6 years, after time making your college price not as substantial.

For CS, what school you graduate from isn’t usually a big deal. At least on the west coast, a degree from HKUST isn’t going to hurt you. The biggest problem you’ll find after you graduate is that you’ll likely need to come to the US to search for a job.

I have a CS degree, and it’s hard for me to imagine that you’ll learn more at UW/UIUC/UCSD than at HKUST. There probably won’t be big differences in what you learn unless you decide to pursue a particular CS specialty at one of those schools.

If it was me, I’d go to school in Hong Kong for the savings.

Yes, the money saved by going to HKUST will more than pay for relocation and job hunting in the US.

For your amusement, here is a world ranking of CS departments in which HKUST came out #9.

http://www.usnews.com/education/best-global-universities/search?region=&subject=computer-science&name=

This ranking does seem a bit goofy, however (e.g. hard to see CMU at #17).

Post #6, it seems kind of goofy but I like this one because it puts UCSD only second to UCB among all the UCs. Haha