College Students: Do You Attend a College that Once Deferred You?

<p>I was deferred from UVA, my first choice since I was in early elementary school. I was OOS (out of state) so it is pretty competitive to get in.</p>

<p>My guidance counselor hounded them for a while, but I didn’t think that really accomplished anything.</p>

<p>When I sent my mid year grade report, I emphasized how I was also taking classes at Villanova (Calculus 3) at night in addition to my 5 APs or whatever my schedule was. I had also dropped one AP that I had an A in because it was my senior year and I figured that if I had gotten deferred anyways, I wasn’t going to put myself through it, so it’s not like I was perfect. I also included a sincere letter with my mid year grades stating how UVA had always been my dream school and why (their education program) and how I would still love to matriculate if they would admit me.</p>

<p>I was shocked when I was admitted RD. I matriculated and have been happy here ever since. I did not consider deferral as a reason why I should not be here, I know the odds of OOS students getting admitted and I just knew I had to do more to stand out. I have a 3.7 here so I know I belong, it is just the politics of the admissions that might have kept me out.</p>

<p>My D was deferred from EA Villanova (along with many others).
She was accepted during the regular decision process , and is now a freshman and very happy.</p>

<p>All she did additionally was have her mid term transcript sent , which all RD applicants would have done.</p>

<p>I was deferred from UPenn ED and later accepted during regular decision. </p>

<p>During that time I had talked with the admissions rep who recommended I send a letter affirming my desire for Penn as my first choice.</p>

<p>I decided to go with a bit of a creative letter, discussing the various ways I would try and get into Penn, apparently it worked out.</p>

<p>Can you give us some of the more “creative” excerpts from that Penn letter, tennisjump?</p>

<p>Thanks!</p>

<p>@hazelorb</p>

<p>How exactly did you emphasis that you were taking Calculus 3 at Villanova? I’m taking Calculus 3, Linear Algebra, and Abstract algebra this semester at the University of Pittsburgh and am wondering if I could possibly work rigorous coursework like this that I up took in high school to my advantage.</p>

<p>The following is about a girl I know who was waitlisted, not deferred, but same diff.</p>

<p>[Student</a> Profile: Ann Cheng - US News and World Report](<a href=“http://www.usnews.com/articles/education/best-colleges/2008/08/21/student-profile-ann-cheng.html]Student”>http://www.usnews.com/articles/education/best-colleges/2008/08/21/student-profile-ann-cheng.html)</p>

<p>She wrote Harvard one short letter about her commitment to the school and sent them updates on significant awards. She was accepted off the waitlist on the evening of May 23rd, 2008, if I remember correctly.</p>

<p>The mid year grade report had these directions:
“In the chart below, list all the courses you have attempted and grades you have earned during the 2005–2006 academic year as they appear on your
transcript. Clearly note any AP, IB, honors, college, or dual-enrollment courses. If you have dropped or added courses, please note on chart below.”
So I just listed them as courses.</p>

<p>I just sent my letter to Penn today and I included a rather creative video link that I crafted myself which emphasizes my love for Penn. My letter was also somewhat creative but also included many of my accomplishments.</p>

<p>Let’s see how this goes for me. Wish me luck for April!!</p>

<p>I was deferred frown Brown ED this year, but along with my midyear grades I included a recommendation letter from the superintendent and a really personal letter reaffirming the reasons Brown is my top choice. So I’m in the same boat as hardworker… hopefully we’ll both have happy endings to report come April!</p>

<p>I got waitlisted one of my schools that I really wanted to attend. I sent them e-mails at least once a week telling them how great I was doing in my classes along with personal achievements. At the bottom of each e-mail I did a top 10 reasons why they should accept me. Surprisingly enough after I sent the last e-mail I got another e-mail saying I had been accepted. One of the admissions interns told me that they were planning on accepting me off the waitlist and left a space open for me but they just had to see all my reasons. </p>

<p>Furthermore I also had a student at the school, a teacher who attended the school, my college counselor and my head of school all write recs for me. I also did a phone interview.</p>

<p>Would you guys recommend sending a letter through email or just type it up and fax to admissions?</p>

<p>You should mail it through snail mail, not email or fax.</p>

<p>My friend is currently deferred from Stanford EA, her first choice. She has been keeping in touch with the admissions office about her accomplishments so far in senior year (straight A’s, with 3 or 4 APs, first place in some crew regattas, service, etc). She hopes she’ll be accepted with the RD’ers, but only time will tell.</p>

<p>I know a student who was convinced he was going to be accepted EA to G’town as a recruited athlete last year. He was really cocky about it in November, but by December when everyone else was hearing about their acceptances, he was eating dirt. With his tail between his legs, he got more serious about his schoolwork, sent out lots of new applications, and had his coach and GC write letters. He got in. So glad Georgetown put him on hold, as it was a good wake-up call.</p>

<p>Would love to hear some more tips on changing the deferred to accepted. My D was deferred from her top 3 choices and has called, written and asked for interviews. She has also gotten another LOR from her Trig/Calculus teacher (Math was her weakness on the SAT) in which she is getting an A-/B+. She has told her top choice that if she is admitted she will definitely attend.</p>

<p>I was deferred from my first choice (Villanova) and I’m really thinking about sending another recommendation and a personal letter. I got a 4.33 GPA this past semester, so I can definitely talk about that, as it was my strongest semester of my high school career. Will it help?</p>

<p>I got deferred from my first choice (Bucknell) I sent in a personal letter outlining why my grades where **** poor and just about me and reaffirming that Bucknell was still my first choice.</p>

<p>I also had a youth leader write me a letter of reccomendation.</p>

<p>I’ll find out in march, -fingers crossed-</p>

<p>how should I approach this letter? does anyone have any examples?</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Check out this “Ask the Dean” column. [How</a> Do I Send Resume Updates to Colleges? - Ask The Dean](<a href=“http://www.collegeconfidential.com/dean/archives/how-do-i-send-resume-updates-to-colleges.htm]How”>http://www.collegeconfidential.com/dean/archives/how-do-i-send-resume-updates-to-colleges.htm)</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Usually I agree. BUT … if you have previously exchanged email messages with the admission rep who oversees candidates from your school, I recommend sending a snail-mail letter to the office of admission and also e-mail a copy to this rep, with a note on the top saying something brief like, “FYI–just mailed this to the admission office but wanted to call it to your attention in particular. As you can tell, I’m still really eager to attend [name of college].” </p>

<p>Of course, if you use email, make sure your full name, school name, and school city/state (or country) are in the email. It’s not going to work in your favor if the admission official sees only “SurferBabe92” on the “From” line.</p>

<p>I wrote a post earlier that I think could provide some helpful information on the topic of deferrals. I wrote several letters to Tufts and kept them updated of grades, spoke with professors, and generally tried to keep myself on their radar to show that I wanted to attend throughout the normal decision admissions period. </p>

<hr>

<p>As a Tufts grad who was deferred ED round 1, I hope that my story will offer some comfort to those who were deferred as well as those who find themselves rejected from their top choice schools. Here it goes…</p>

<p>After touring more than 15 schools (Tufts three times), I decided that Tufts was my top choice and decided to apply early decision. I came from a very small, very competitive public high school and out of 135 kids in my graduating class, 5 students applied early decision. My first quarter Senior Year, I made sure to challenge myself with 4 AP’s, pursued a wide variety of extracurriculars, leadership roles, etc…basically I felt that I was a competitive applicant and spent hours upon hours perfecting my personal statement, the “why tufts” question, and every detail of the application.</p>

<p>I worked my tuchus off throughout high school, and my grades in 4 of my 5 classes first quarter were all A’s. However, to my chagrin, my AP Calc AB teacher was extremely difficult and despite being a very strong math student, my first quarter grade in Calculus was a 79. It was just one of those classes where the teacher was infamous for not being the most personable (for example, as someone who was qualified for extended timing during exams, this teacher would force me to hand in the exams before my alloted time and did not accommodate to my needs, obviously resulting in a less than optimal grade). This simply seemed unfair- after all, I tried my hardest, yet there was an obvious disparity in my teacher’s approach that resulted in me getting screwed.</p>

<p>When December 15th rolled around, I was almost expecting the deferral…I felt like my application was qualified, with the exception of that one fat C+. I knew admissions would find it suspicious that I had an A in AP Stats, did very well on the SAT and SAT II Math, yet had this lower grade in the quarter that is arguably the most important for me to prove myself academically.</p>

<p>My initial reaction was extreme frustration, to the point that I began to simply place Tufts out of the picture. Yet, particularly now in retrospect, I think that Tufts made a very accurate call. They essentially agreed with me, that my application was strong enough to be considered for admission during the normal round, yet they would like more time for me to show them that I that I could improve the math grade.</p>

<p>I wasn’t going to let this challenge, particularly this one math teacher’s bizarre teaching habits, get in the way of my future. As a result, I made time each week to meet with her and go over the material, making sure that we were both on the same page, that she knew how much I cared about grasping the material and that I was able to get to know her and make her understand that my documented extended timing was not a luxury, but rather a necessity for me to reach to my potential.</p>

<p>However, independent of this one math class, being deferred allowed me to reflect a lot on what I wanted out of college. I realized that, while I really really liked Tufts, there were several schools that I would be perfectly happy to attend. I think that this realization is essential- that a truly successful college experience is extremely individualized, and while it certainly involves taking the time to do the research on what school is the “best fit,” what I believe to be the most important indicator of a successful college student is a student who comes into college with the passions and drive to take advantage of available resources and create his or her own success. The latter is something that you have each already developed throughout your lives, and to say that there is only one school that will allow you to thrive is simply ridiculous.</p>

<p>Being deferred was also a blessing in disguise because it kept me on my A-game and I completely avoided the “Senior Slump.” (It still makes me laugh, by the way, to think of the students who were accepted early to their first choice and attempted to acquire pity through saying how “difficult it is to motivate myself to do work now that I’ve already been accepted.” PLEASE- it’s like the kid who is the first among your friends to be done with finals and wanders around saying how bored they are with nothing to do…give me a break). I ended up bringing my math grade up and maintaining strong grades in my other courses, and my senior year was the by far the most challenging yet the most rewarding.</p>

<p>When late March came around, I had a completely different outlook. Out of the 14 schools to which I applied, (low self esteem at time of deferral and over-paranoid guidance counselor results in this), I had expanded my list of “perfect match dream schools” from just Tufts to 5 schools, and realized that even if those 5 did not work out, I would still be quite happy and make the most out of the others.</p>

<p>Long story short, I ended up getting accepted to 13 out of the 14 schools, Tufts included. Was I ecstatic about Tufts? Of course. However, my academic and personal growth during those 3 months as a result of being deferred undoubtedly made me a stronger person, regardless of whether I was accepted to Tufts or not. My work ethic was stronger than ever and that very same teacher who I couldn’t stand earlier in the year ended up giving me a math achievement award during graduation. I’m not saying any of this to brag, but rather to show the importance of not letting initial setbacks dictate your future outlook and actions. It is during these times of extreme challenge that you have the opportunity to turn things around and experience the most growth.</p>

<p>I am confident that whether you were accepted, deferred, or rejected, that you can each go on and make the most out of your college experience and do incredible things. If, for whatever reason, the admissions committee feels that you are not the right fit, you have to take it with a grain of salt. I know such an outlook may seem quite difficult at the moment, but just remember that whatever college you get into and attend is lucky to have you and things will work out in the end!</p>

<p>Best of luck :-)</p>