I’ll give you a couple of offbeat options:
How about Prescott College in Prescott, AZ. Very cool LITTLE school in a cool little town. Great weather (it’s not super-hot there, like in Phoenix, higher altitude). But really the campus is the global environment. Students build their own curriculum, and it’s very environmentally oriented. We know a student who went there very recently who spent their college years pretty much in high mountains all around the world. There’s a film featuring her.
http://www.prescott.edu
How about UNC-Asheville? It is a public LAC in a great, great town. I believe total costs for OOS freshmen would be under $40k, without aid, pretty cheap for an OOS public. Asheville and UNC-A are big arts centers.
Kalamazoo College in Michigan is really an underrated LAC. You can get an outstanding education there.
http://www.kzoo.edu/k-plan/
I don’t know Trinity University in San Antonio, TX, but people seem to love it. And San Antonio is great. And you wouldn’t have to be there in the summer, when it is just too hot (but winters are great).
https://new.trinity.edu
Okay, how about the opposite of a city or a suburb–a mountain. I just love the admissions video and would like to live here. Great academics too.
http://admission.sewanee.edu
What about international study? Use your college years to see the world. Besides Great Britain and Australia, the Netherlands has “University Colleges” attached to several large universities. These are patterned after US LACs. Classes are in English (though Dutch students may prefer Dutch in social settings, which might be a challenge). There are ones in Amsterdam and Utrecht and several other cities. You can easily travel all over northern Europe from these cities. I don’t think they cost US students more than $15k or so per year and it is a 3-year program. Here’s a link for University College Utrecht,
https://www.uu.nl/en/organisation/university-college-utrecht
I’d think you’d be competitive at all these schools. Good luck!