** Columbia University Class of 2020 RD Results **

Decision: Accepted - CC

Objective:
SAT 2: 770 Eng Lit, 800 French, 640 Chem (didn’t send last one unless required)
ACT: 33 C (35 E, 35 R, 30 M, 33 S)
UW GPA: 4.0 (I’m at an Ontario high school with 95/100 UW grades… Different grading system than US so my counselor told me schools add on 10-15%. Was therefore told my grades correspond to 4.0 USA GPA)
W GPA: n/a (school doesn’t offer AP classes)
APs: 5 (French – self study)
Rank: Valedictorian
Senior Year Load: Intensive Chemistry for First-Years; Intensive Calculus and Logic for First-Years (both at the University of Toronto); Grade 12 English; Grade 12 Physics

Subjective:

Major ECs: Research assistant at one of the top chem research labs in Canada; Singing, acting (all 4 years); working in hospital over summer in Nepal following earthquake on full grant; classes + volunteering in Israel during Israeli-Gazan conflict; black belt in tae-kwon-do
Essays: 8-9/10 on all, some of my best writing. Various essays about unique and painful circumstances growing up, living in a warzone, working in a hospital after a major natural disaster

Teacher Rec #1: Science teacher, told me I’m one of the best students he’s ever taught.
Teacher Rec #2: Mandarin teacher, was 1-on-1 with him a lot of the class, close friends! Amazing guy, solid rec.
Counselor Rec: Don’t know him super well, but he likes me well enough and I’m confident he wrote a great rec.
Additional Rec: From the head prof at my chem lab. He’s the sweetest guy and likes me a lot. He’s also sort of famous in the academia world!
Interview: N/A

Other

Applied for Financial Aid?: Yup
Intended Major: Astrophysics
State (if domestic applicant): raised in TX
Country (if international applicant): currently live in Toronto, Canada
School Type: Private
Ethnicity: Biracial caucasian + native american
Gender: Female
Income Bracket: Low
Hooks (URM, first generation college, etc.): semi-URM, female in STEM

Reflection

Strengths – I think I have a very unique story. Unique ECs
Weaknesses – Test scores
Where else were you accepted/deferred/rejected:
Accepted: UPenn, Dartmouth, Johns Hopkins, NYU, UCs (Berkeley, LA, SD, Davis, SB), UVa in Canada: UofT, McGill, UBC, Queen’s
Rejected: Harvard (deferred EA then rejected), Yale, Yale-NUS, Princeton, Stanford, Cornell, Rice, USC
Waitlisted: Brown

General Comments:

Super excited, going for a visit to DOC2 to confirm my decision but am THIS close to committing. No regrets, super happy with where I ended up. Go lions!

Decision: Accepted - SEAS

Objective:
SAT I (breakdown): 2370 (800 R, 770 M, 800 W)
ACT (breakdown): -
SAT II: 800 Math II, 800 Chemistry, 730 Biology
Unweighted GPA (out of 4.0): -
Rank (percentile if rank is unavailable): -
AP (place score in parenthesis): 5 CS A, 5 Chemistry
IB (place score in parenthesis): -
Senior Year Course Load: AP BC Calc, AP Physics C, AP US Gov’t & Politics, Essay Writing, local college CS course, CS independent study
Major Awards (USAMO, Intel etc.): -

Subjective:

Extracurriculars (place leadership in parenthesis): Track team (mid-level leader), robotics team (minor member), Wikipedia editor (actually, almost an administrator (for you other Wikipedia editors out there, template editor, bot developer, and a few transcluded gadgets)
Job/Work Experience: -
Volunteer/Community service: Front desk at a local health center for a couple of years
Summer Activities: STEM program at another local college
Essays (rating 1-10, details): Common App (7; I’m not a good writer), Columbia Engineering (7; I thought I got some good examples across)

Teacher Rec #1: Math teacher (8; had a great relationship)
Teacher Rec #2: Social studies teacher (7; thought I had a good relationship, but since I’m a math person, that probably showed in my attitude towards the class)
Counselor Rec: 8 (visited her a lot, unlike a lot of my peers in my grade)
Additional Rec: 7 (Track coach; don’t think he likes me)
Interview: 8 (got a current student; I think I talked about STEM stuff enough to make her mildly interested)

Other

Applied for Financial Aid?: nope
Intended Major: Computer science
State (if domestic applicant): NY
Country (if international applicant): USA
School Type: Public
Ethnicity: Half white, half asian
Gender: Male
Income Bracket: ~200K
Hooks (URM, first generation college, etc.): -

Reflection

Strengths: Dad went to SEAS; mom went to Barnard; aunt and uncle went to SEAS; pretty good Columbia Engineering essay
Weaknesses: Practically no leadership. No awards whatsoever. No science research whatsoever. No “social” extracurriculars whatsoever. Minimal volunteering.
Why you think you were accepted/deferred/rejected: Legacy
Where else were you accepted/deferred/rejected:I tried my best to convey a lot of interest in STEM and how I would further my interests in STEM through my essays and interviews.

General Comments: Also accepted at Cornell Eng.

Decision: Waitlisted then Accepted - CC

Objective:
SAT I (breakdown): 2360 (780 CR, 800 M, 780 W)
SAT II: 790 M2 and 750 Physics
Unweighted GPA (out of 4.0): 3.76 (Hardest rigor possible at a “Top-10” Prep school. I also noted that my father isn’t really around because he travels for work, and that my mom was extremely sick for the first two years of high school, forcing me to take on a lot more responsibility - this basically included taking care of my younger brother)
Weighted GPA: NA
Rank: NA
AP (place score in parenthesis): Calculus BC (5 self-studied in 10th grade), Statistics (5),Macroeconomics (5 self-studied in 11th grade), Spanish Lang (5), US History (4), Physics 1 (4 self-studied 11th grade), Microeconomics (4 self-studied 11th grade)
IB (place score in parenthesis): NA
Senior Year Course Load: Non-Euclidean Geometry (Fall), Honors English, AP Physics C Mechanics (Fall), Astronomy (Fall), AP Computer Science, AP Physics C E&M (Spring), Number Theory (Spring), Advanced Microbiology (Spring), Theatrical Productions (Fall)

Major Awards (USAMO, Intel etc.): Published Poet, National Merit Commended, AP Scholar with Distinction. Nothing crazy.

Subjective:

Extracurriculars (place leadership in parenthesis):
Listed on app:
Debate Club [9-12, President during 11-12]: Intra-school club that fosters an environment in which students can defend their positions on various topics. (360 hours total) Fencing [11-12]: School team (100 hours total)
Theater/Drama [9-12]: I played a chorus member in “Guys and Dolls,” Herrick in “The Crucible,” Boatswain in “The Tempest,” and Macbeth in “Macbeth” (384 hours total)
Successful SF Kids Co-President [9-11]: This program takes students from my independent school to a low-income public school once a week, and has them tutor these kids in numerous subjects. (270 hours total)
Kung Fu [9-12, Blackbelt]: Weekly Kung Fu practices at the academy and at home, with occasional tournaments (I have won several awards, including a first place trophy). (320 hours total)
Admissions Ambassador for HS [11-12]: I work open houses, speak on parent and student panels, represent my school at high school fairs, give school tours, and interact with applicants. (60 hours total)

Job/Work Experience:
Substance Cataloguing at Biotech firm [9-10]: I catalogued the various substances and chemicals at this Biomedical firm into a newly appointed state system, and generally helped manage inventory. (120 hours total)

Volunteer/Community Service:
Non-profit Admissions Board [11-12): Responsibilities include interviewing low-income middle schoolers for this tutoring non profit, reading applications, and deciding whether to admit. (108 hours total)
English and Math Tutor [9-11]: During trips to India, I tutor children in Gurgaon (small city outside Delhi) and Dharavi (slum in Mumbai) in mathematics and english. (300 hours total)

Summer Activities:
During the summer of 2013, I visited family and tutored kids in India, and then returned home to work at a Biotech firm, as explained above.
During the summer of 2014, I interned at an international observatory in Chile - I helped in their library (yes, I went to Chile to be a library volunteer), redesigned part of their website, and attended various lectures with all sorts of renowned scientists who humbled me greatly. I then came back to America to take Linear Algebra + Diff Eq at UCLA, which I completed in the top quartile (honestly, probably the top decile) of my class.
During the summer of 2015, I studied theoretical physics + astronomy at the Harvard Summer School. Noted this, but couldn’t submit the grades (sucks too, because I got As in both classes).

Essays (rating 1-10, details):
Common App [9/10]: I was really proud of this essay, as it attacked the dismissive undertone of the word “talent” (i.e. when someone says you’re so lucky because you’re “talented” in an area, they effectively diminish all the effort you’ve put in). I used this argument to segue into how I’ve built up my math considerably, and how much I enjoy math for its puzzle-solving nature.
Various Columbia Essays [8/10]: They showed why I liked Columbia for its quirkiness, affirmed my interest in the Core Curriculum, and spoke about my love of math and tutoring.
Waitlist Letter [10/10]: Pretty much a generic update on my semester (keeping grades up, reading these books, etc.). However, I was able to talk about a recent research publication in this letter - I’m pretty sure this is the reason I was accepted.

Recommendations (rating 1-10, details):
Teacher Rec #1 [9/10]: Math teacher. He taught me everything from Multivariable Calculus to AP Statistics to Non-Euclidean Geometry. We’ve had our ups and downs, but I know that he really cares about how I do, so I’m sure this was great.
Teacher Rec #2 [7-10/10]: English Teacher for 1 semester/Academic Dean. So I’m not sure how this recommendation was, as I only had this teacher for a semester. That being said, I know I was probably the top student in her class, and my college counselor told me that she writes amazing recommendations, so this could’ve been really solid.
Counselor Rec [10/10]: He was an admissions counselor at Stanford, and he’s one of the most-informed people I met, so I feel like he would’ve written a great recommendation. Plus, I know that I’m basically his favorite student in the grade, so I’m sure this was amazing.
Additional Rec [8/10]: UCLA Linear Algebra + Diff Eq. Professor. I was the youngest student in the class by far, but I know I was one of the top students (we were told the final grade distribution in the class). Apparently, he was a big deal at MIT some years ago when he was an undergraduate, and wrote about how impressively competent I was by comparing me to that environment. My college counselor read it, and said it was great.
Interview [10/10]: Literally, my best interview. We sat in a cafe for 2-3 hours, and talked about Columbia, politics, San Francisco, and everything in between. At the end of the interview, she actually walked me to my car so we could keep talking. Additionally, she contacted admissions on my behalf when I was waitlisted - this definitely helped my case.

Other

Applied for Financial Aid?: No
Intended Major: Math
State (if domestic applicant): CA
Country (if international applicant):
School Type: Private
Ethnicity: Asian (basically death)
Gender: M
Income Bracket: $300,000+
Hooks (URM, first generation college, etc.): None, sadly.

Reflection

Strengths: SAT score, extracurriculars, recommendations, research, and essays in my opinion.
Weaknesses: GPA - Holy moly this was so terrible as an Asian male applying to elite colleges.
Why you think you were accepted/waitlisted/rejected: I think I was initially waitlisted because of my math, and later accepted because of the research publication. However, this process was much harder for me because of my low GPA.
Where else were you accepted/waitlisted/rejected: Accepted: UMich, UCLA, UCB, Swarthmore, UChicago, Villanova, Boston University, New York University, and now COLUMBIA. Waitlisted: Amherst, Williams, Wesleyan, Wash U, Georgetown
Rejected: HYPS, Cornell, Dartmouth, Penn, and Northwestern.

General Comments: College admissions is a total crapshoot. I was rejected from literally every ivy, yet I somehow managed to get into Columbia despite my absurdly low GPA. As an Asian male. Columbia has legit been one of dream schools for an extremely long time, so I am beyond thrilled to say that I’ll be attending next fall. Hopefully this post shows all other Asians out there, who are currently fretting about their chances like I was a year ago, that it TOTALLY IS POSSIBLE TO DEFY THE ODDS. #ROAR2020