<p>You have repeatedly insisted that schools aren’t supposed to include your standardized test scores on transcripts, but what’s your source for that? A self-serving College Board statement that’s designed to generate revenue by forcing kids to pay for test scores to be sent?</p>
<p>Macalester’s Admission Office clearly has a different take on what information can be included in a high school transcript. I submit that they have a better grasp of what high school transcripts can and cannot include than you do.</p>
<p>Your school transcript may contain lots of extraneous information beyond grades received in classes taken at your high school. And if your school prepares information one standard way (with scores) and you ask them to remove the scores especially for you, a college might notice that if they receive transcripts from other applicants who attend your high school. A college guidance counselor who is aware of a “top school” that has an “all scores” policy might choose to not remove scores if they thought that, by doing so, s/he would be assisting a student who wishes to use Score Choice. Or, that same guidance counselor might get a request from a “top school” that s/he wants to maintain a positive relationship with, and – for the sake of his/her career and the interests of other applicants from your school – deliver your corrected, complete high school transcript in the school’s standard form (with all test scores included, if that’s how that school normally rolls).</p>
<p>You’ve said that you arranged to have the scores removed from your transcript, but it’s entirely possible that they will reappear in later updates. (The school secretary may get it right the first time, but will s/he get it right for each of the reports that get sent out to colleges?) Or consider that a teacher or your guidance counselor could use his or her recommendation to note how you rebounded from poor SAT scores in January and how you really applied yourself to bring the scores up while taking a demanding course load. That would be a very positive, well-meaning statement that is entirely within the relevant material that can be shared…and, yet, at a “top school” asking for “all scores” where you submitted only May test scores, it could land your application folder in the reject bin post haste. So much for it being “impossible” for those schools to get wise to the scam. lol.</p>
<p>I liken your request (to have your high school remove your test scores from your transcript) to being one to remove all disciplinary activity from your transcript. Sure, they may tell you, “Yeah, okay…fine…whatever…” but if you give them a request to send a complete transcript to a college, they’re apt to do just that. They’re not bound to honor College Board’s Score Choice program (though they may now make it a practice to do so, for transcripts sent to Score Choice institutions). If a college guidance counselor, who has his or her own interests to safeguard, knows that some colleges require all scores (which is likely going to be the case for those “top schools” that are on everyone’s radar), a student/applicant may learn that s/he doesn’t have as much control as s/he imagines when it comes to telling the high school what to omit from the school’s standard, complete transcript format. Or, more likely, the student will never learn that the transcript contained all scores despite the request to omit them and, if the student’s having really bad luck, s/he would just get a rejection letter in late March, remaining totally clueless that the college caught on to what the student tried to do.</p>
<p>If this decision is based on playing the odds, consider this. You’ve claimed that a college won’t learn that an applicant used Score Choice. I contend that it is much more likely that the applicant will never learn that the high school transcript or some other piece of information slipped through and exposed that the applicant used Score Choice.</p>
<p>That said, I think the odds are low that the AdComs at “all score” colleges are pointedly looking out for Score Choice users. Their jobs are complicated enough without going on side adventures through applicant files in hopes of finding toxic fruit. And getting discovered may not necessarily result in a fatal blow to your application. But it could happen…and in easily foreseeable ways. It’s not this impossible-to-detect scam that you have claimed it is. And even though it seems you still fail to grasp the ethical reasons to comply, it’s probably a good thing for your application that you’ve wised up to the fact that there are “risks” involved that you’re not willing to take. lol.</p>