<p>Lindsay,
There are a number of sources where student surveys have been done and which touch on a number of the items you list as important to you. </p>
<p>One source is Sparknotes. Below is how the schools in the USWNR Top 30 National Universities compared on the following questions:</p>
<p>1 . Felt that faculty involvement was better than at most colleges
2 . Felt that students's work habits were balanced
3 . Felt that the dorms were palaces or at least, not too shabby
4 . Felt that their campus was equal to Heaven on Earth
5 . Felt that their classes were more than they ever expected and/or were inspired by them</p>
<p>Rank Based on Student Responses , Total Points , College</p>
<p>1 , 16 , Princeton***</p>
<p>2 , 32 , Notre Dame***
3 , 38 , Vanderbilt***</p>
<p>4 , 50 , Dartmouth***
5 , 51 , Wake Forest***
6 , 51 , Yale***
7 , 52 , Emory***
8 , 57 , Stanford***
9 , 58 , U Chicago***
10 , 60 , Rice***
11 , 61 , Duke***
12 , 61 , Cal Tech***
13 , 62 , U Virginia***
14 , 68 , Wash U StL***
15 , 69 , U Penn
16 , 73 , Brown***
17 , 79 , Georgetown***
18 , 79 , U North Carolina***</p>
<p>19 , 90 , Tufts***
20 , 91 , Cornell
21 , 95 , Columbia</p>
<p>22 , 105 , USC
23 , 107 , UC Berkeley
24 , 111 , U Michigan
25 , 112 , J Hopkins
26 , 114 , UCLA
27 , 115 , MIT
28 , 116 , Northwestern***
29 , 118 , Carnegie Mellon
30 , 120 , Harvard***</p>
<p>***indicates college was recognized by USNWR for Classroom Teaching Excellence</p>
<p>A 2nd source is Fiske’s Guide to Colleges. They compare based on academics, social life and quality of life. With regard to your inquiry about social life, here is how the USNWR Top 50 National Universities compare:</p>
<p>Fiske Social Life Rating College</p>
<p>5 , Dartmouth
5 , Penn State</p>
<p>4 , Stanford
4 , Brown
4 , U Virginia
4 , Duke
4 , U North Carolina
4 , UCSD
4 , Wash U
4 , Georgetown
4 , U Wisconsin
4 , U Texas
4 , Cornell
4 , Vanderbilt
4 , UC Berkeley
4 , UC Santa Barbara
4 , U Florida
4 , Boston Coll
4 , Tulane
4 , Lehigh</p>
<p>3 , Harvard
3 , Columbia
3 , Rice
3 , Tufts
3 , Princeton
3 , Yale
3 , U Penn
3 , MIT
3 , Northwestern
3 , Emory
3 , UCLA
3 , U Michigan
3 , W&M
3 , U Illinois
3 , UC Davis
3 , Johns Hopkins
3 , NYU
3 , U Washington
3 , Notre Dame
3 , Carnegie Mellon
3 , Wake Forest
3 , Brandeis
3 , U Rochester
3 , Rensselaer
3 , USC
3 , Syracuse</p>
<p>2 , U Chicago
2 , Georgia Tech
2 , Case Western
2 , UC Irvine</p>
<p>1 , Caltech</p>
<p>Finally, I created a thread about social life at top colleges and there were many, many responses. Here is the thread (and I hope that anyone who is so inclined will add their own rankings) and the up-to-date “rankings” as voted on by CC contributors. </p>
<p><a href="http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/college-search-selection/348753-ranking-social-life-usnwr-top-20-a.html%5B/url%5D">http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/college-search-selection/348753-ranking-social-life-usnwr-top-20-a.html</a></p>
<p>1 Vanderbilt
2 Stanford
3 Duke
4 Dartmouth
5 U Penn
6 Notre Dame
7 Northwestern
8 Rice
9 Cornell
10 Brown
11 Princeton
12 Wash U
13 Harvard
14 Yale
15 Emory
16 Columbia
17 MIT
18 Johns Hopkins
19 U Chicago
20 Caltech</p>