Preface: I don’t mean to brag about anything, I’m just stating things to provide context so as to get more informed answers.
I’ve been doing debate since middle school, and I’ve always excelled at it - this continued in high school, where I was able to do well at the local and state level in 9th grade.
After placing 1st in local championships, I qualified for NCFL Grand Nats in both 10th and 11th grade. I was made a co-captain of the Public Forum team (“PF captain”) for my junior year, working with another PF captain (my debate partner) and serving under two Head Captains, who oversee the entire team and all its sub-teams for different debate formats.
Now, I’m being offered a chance to be a co-head captain with my partner. Normally I would leap at the opportunity, but after a really grindy junior year, I don’t want to add unnecessary stress during my senior year if it won’t really benefit me from an admissions standpoint, and would rather remain as a PF captain.
Head captainship appears to be very tough, in that you’re not just teaching debate like I would as a PF captain, but you’re managing the entire team - the dues, tournament registration, and so much stuff.
Does my title/role actually matter? Or is the relevant part colleges will look at be more about how I’ve been able to do well at debate and pass on my experience/knowledge to my high school peers?
Honestly I haven’t really started any college essays except the Common App Essay in which I will be talking about something other than debate, so I don’t really know what role debate plays yet or like how/if I’ll write about it. So far I’ve just done the Activities section of the Common App, in which I’ve listed my title as PF Captain.