Not sure so clear that is right for Vandy ED; and will depend on HS.
First of all, I think you have to think about your “impact of an explanation” question in terms of tiered pools of applicants. Can a compelling explanation move you from the “ruled out based on grades” pool to the “not ruled out based on grades” pool? Yes, probably, especially if that explanation is backed up by your recommenders, particularly your guidance counselor, whose job it is to contextualize your application.
But, at schools like Vandy and Yale, they’re still rejecting an overwhelming majority of the “not ruled out” pool. And no explanation will make your transcript look better than that of an applicant with a strong record all the way through high school; all it’s doing is mitigating a liability, sufficiently to get your application a second look. There’s still a steep hill to climb after that, to make that second look more convincing than those of maybe 80% (at Vandy) all those other qualified applicants… or 90% if its Yale.
This is why I think a “super-senior” AFS year or similar could put you in a stronger position - you’d be adding a new, valuable dimension to your record, giving yourself time to show consistency at your new level of performance, and putting the more rocky early years farther in the rear view mirror. From an AO’s point of view, one good year rather than three is a lot to overcome. Two good years plus a challenging and broadening post-grad experience would be a significant shift and assure AO’s that your junior year wasn’t a fluke or an unsustainable burst of motivation.
That said, a gap year is worth doing only if you see inherent value in it; otherwise, go wherever you can get in this year, and you’ll be fine! There are many great options if the “T20” tier doesn’t pan out. I like the U of Denver suggestion; look in particular at the Pioneer Leadership cohort program - it sounds like your EC’s could position you well for that. Denison could be another good one to look at. It’s near the state capitol of Columbus, has strong political majors (both Poli Sci and “Politics and Public Affairs,” plus the interdisciplinary “PPE” major: Philosophy, Politics, and Economics) with a particularly strong semester-in-DC program, and it has a Women’s and Gender Studies major/minor program with strong interactions with other departments including poli sci. It’s also strong in the data-driven side of social sciences, with a Data Analytics major that can be focused on the political arena, and a minor in Data for Political Research. Lots of cool things you could do at Denison.
I honestly don’t think it would make much of a difference for a T20 school. I think you need more realistic choices. You can apply to the top…but realistically fall in “love” with some target schools as well.
1 Like
Linking to OP’s other thread, with GPA and other stats: Bad Grades Freshman/Sophomore Year - #13 by tsbna44
1 Like
This is just anecdotal, based on one student’s experience. But . . . my son’s situation was remarkably similar to yours in every way and overshooting for ED1 did not work out for him. His situation: untreated ADHD freshman and sophomore years, resulting in some average grades (although no C’s - a mix of B’s and A’s). Started taking medication junior year resulting in a big improvement in his grades (nearly all A’s). Had high test scores - 1520 SAT - and strong extracurriculars. He shot high for ED1, and applied to Middlebury, where he had legacy (I went there), and a great admissions interview. It was also a great fit for him in terms of his interests - he took two languages in high school and Middlebury is well-known for its excellence in languages. He included a brief statement in the “Additional Information” section of the Common App, explaining his ADHD and that he went on medication starting in junior year which resulted in a huge leap in his academic accomplishments. He was rejected . . . not even deferred (which is the result I thought he would get).
He got a happy ending and was later accepted to Bates for ED2, which is where he’ll attend. Hindsight is 20-20, but looking back, Middlebury was too heavy a lift for him given his grades even with everything else he had going for him.
Vanderbilt is a much heavier lift than Middlebury, and Yale even more so. I think both are likely shooting way too high. Your test scores are great, but grades are much more important, and, like others, I think you would need some sort of exceptional outside accomplishment in your extracurriculars to overcome your lower grades, even for Vanderbilt. Based on your description or yourself, you will get into a great school! I would consider some of the suggestions from some of the prior posts as a starting point
3 Likes
Bates is a great school as well…Congratulations!!!
2 Likes
Based on that GPA, and the academic interests and ADHD challenges, I question whether the OP would be positioning himself for success at large, tippy top places, even in the unlikely event that the turnaround story would convince them. I would use the ED card for quality places in your areas of academic interest that are not as GPA-obsessed and are looking for a particular kind of activist/leader student, like Wesleyan, Oberlin or Occidental which would by no means be safeties or clear matches for that GPA; if you fall in love with any of them. My concern with that type of school would be whether it would regard the OP as a potential drain on resources if the background is discussed, but it seems like OP has no option but to disclose in order the explain the various Cs on the record.
1 Like
Thanks - he’s thrilled to be going there.
delete