<p>Hi bbarty! I’ll throw in a few comments on this thread alongside your midwest thread. I live in WI but I grew up on the east coast and have done 2 eastern school searches with my kids now (with good success!).</p>
<p>Here are my comments on your trip/list:</p>
<p>1) On your other thread, you said your stats were “good, maybe not great.” I don’t know if you mean this in a “CC” way, or in an absolute way. I don’t want to be harsh, but if your GPA isn’t pretty close to a 4.0, ACT below 30 and SATs not in the 700s, your schools are very reach-heavy. I hate talking like this, but it’s true when they say any school that accepts fewer than 20% of its applicants is a reach for anybody. </p>
<p>2) On the other thread, you said you liked both Northwestern for its exciting resources, larger-sized and more active campus, and proximity to the city, AND you liked Grinnell’s intimacy and “college-y” feeling, while you weren’t so keen on its isolated rural location. OK - this is really excellent information for you to use in narrowing down your list. You have a lot of Northwestern-like schools (Columbia, Yale, etc.), and a couple of Grinnell-like (Bowdoin, and to a certain extent Wesleyan and Amherst). How OK are you with the remote locations? You’re going to do a lot of driving to see a couple of schools that you might already know you won’t particularly like.</p>
<p>3) Having done several of these trips, and NEVER with a younger sibling in tow nor trying to have a nice vacation at the same time (although we did manage to see family and also fit in a lot of theatre when we were in NYC) - I will say that you have too many on your list. You can do 2 schools in one day if they are VERY close - Columbia and NYU; Northeastern University and Tufts - but not if there is a significant drive, and not repeatedly. After 2-3 schools, you general need a nice day off to digest and not get overloaded. Our trips have averaged 2-3 schools per 3-4 day cycle, and not all of them with actual tours - and again, this is one mom and one kid, no complications. Our biggest trip was 7 schools in 8 days; only 3 were full-fledged tours, and all were within 45 min of Manhattan (basically a tour of the periphery).</p>
<p>4) I’m familiar with pretty much all of those schools. I echo the advice not to duplicate visits to schools that are not all that different in size, style, location or selectivity. Visit schools as “examples” as much as you can. My D1 used visits to whittle her needs down to “mid-size, real college feel, suburban with good city access.” D2 had much the same criteria, interestingly - but she was OK with a longer train ride to a city if the school had her very specific preferred programs. D1 and great stats and could base her apps on that; D2 not quite so great and was going to audition at about half of her schools, so she had to balance her list in many ways to maximize her results. So we had to be efficient in visiting, not do too much “duplicating,” so she could make sure she had lots of options.</p>
<p>After 5-6 college visits, D2 got so she could do the kind of “drive-by” visits you’ve been talking about. But she did take in-depth tours of safety and lower match schools for the reasons the above posters mentioned. Don’t load on Ivies, or top-20 LACs, please. Look closely at the others. We know what it’s like to be out in the midwest and desperately wondering how we’re going to visit or revisit eastern schools in the spring when the results are in.</p>
<p>In case you’re interested - my 4.0 UW/31 ACT kid got accepted ED to Tufts (it met all of her criteria and hit her strongly as the “perfect” school as soon as she stepped on campus); my 3.6 UW/31 ACT kid - who was looking for a strong theatre program preferably a BFA - got into UMinn, Bard College, Goucher College, URI, SUNY New Paltz (auditioned), Adelphi University (auditioned), and Brandeis off the waitlist. She’ll go to Adelphi this fall, in their theatre BFA and Honors College (a UChicago-like Great Books program) with a full-tuition merit scholarship.</p>
<p>Good luck to you - I hope your family can have a nice vacation to New York and New England, while you get some really great college information. It’s doable. But you’re going to have to be very practical and focused.</p>