I need to pick the college I’m going to, and I need help because I’m “torn.” The schools I’m choosing between are Columbia, UPenn, Cornell, Brown and Dartmouth. I got into a lot of other schools, but I’m going to an Ivy.
I applied as an English/Comparative Literature (Brown) major, I think I’m probably going to double major in something and English, I don’t know.
I really like colleges that give off the quintessential college vibe with gothic architecture and pretty campuses, I want the school to have a really good sense of community and a social scene.
My top three so far are Columbia, UPenn, and Brown (in no specific order). My parents want me to go to Columbia, it’s their dream school for my sisters and I, and I’m the youngest and only one to get into Ivies. I don’t dislike it but I grew up in Queens, NYC, and Columbia doesn’t have my preferred campus as it’s in the city. I like the urban-suburban vibe.
I like UPenn, the campus is nice, and I’ve heard a lot. Brown is also pretty nice, I like all the schools though lol.
If anyone has advice, or goes there and can say anything about it, that would be great! Thanks in advance!
College Results:
I got into Boston College, Colgate, Franklin & Marshall, Ithaca, Northwestern (Medill School of Journalism), Syracuse (S.I. Newhouse School of Public Communications), Washington University in St. Louis (WashU), Wheaton, and Tufts, Wesleyan, Bucknell, Cornell, Brown, UPenn, Dartmouth, and NYU
Waitlisted: Harvard & Yale
Rejected: Clark University
You got into five Ivies and were rejected from Clark? Astonishing.
I went to Columbia and teach at Penn. IMO, there’s little to choose between Columbia and Penn, except Columbia is in NYC, Penn isn’t and undergrads there can major in business (Wharton). I know little about Brown except my sister-in-law went there and loved it.
All three of your preferred schools have urban campuses; your best choice which is “urban-suburban” is Tufts, but it would be crazy to pick that when you have a choice of five Ivies. If I were you, I’d give Dartmouth another look. My brother went there and loved it. For pretty campuses, Dartmouth wins. For Gothic architecture, Penn wins among your choices, but why didn’t you apply to Princeton?
Brown is the polar opposite of cutthroat and encourages intellectual curiosity and that students find themselves in their work. A great foundation for a community of learners. Wesleyan is a mini Brown on a campus with a quintessential college feel. 3000 undergrads make it on the larger size for a LAC, which is probably a good thing for your interests.
Wash U checks all your boxes. Gothic architecture. Not a downtown campus. They have a residential college system much like Yale’s through which to build community. Double majors are encouraged.
Dartmouth grads love Dartmouth & their Dartmouth experience, but a visit should enable a fairly quick decision as Hanover is more rural than suburban.
Columbia may be too close to home & may be a better option for a masters degree in journalims since you have so many outstanding opportunities a bit further from your home.
Brown University grads also love their Brown undergraduate experience. Lots of freedom academically & lots of opportunities upon graduation.
Cornell is rural but large enough so that students should have plenty to do in their spare time.
UPenn is, as noted above, similiar to Columbia in setting &, as an Ivy, equally prestigious. There is some concern, however, about pressure to do well.
Northwestern University’s Medill School of Journalism is very highly regarded & the setting is urban / suburban as you prefer. More similiar to Columbia & UPenn, than to Dartmouth College. Easy to double major. Surprised that you went to the trouble of applying to what is arguably the best journalism school in the world which is in your preferred setting, yet it is not among your final group of schools that you are considering. (If it helps, although not in the Ivy League, NU is ranked above Dartmouth, Brown, & Cornell by US News.) But, either you want to major in journalism or you don’t.
I’m from Queens and I well understand the pressure to attend a charter member of the Ivy League, especially if your family as a whole has been through multiple application cycles!
here’s my fly-on-the-wall analysis of your choices:
Dartmouth - Avoid if you are African-American and have not visited. It is the most polarized of the Ivies.
Cornell - Not in a city, but more like a large town in itself. It is your best bet, if you are a fan of Gothic archiitecture.
Columbia - Frankly, I didn’t even apply to Columbia because I was so anxious to get out of the City. And, it doesn’t check the box on Gothic architecture.
Penn - Checks a lot of boxes, including a very peculiar brand of Gothic architecture. If you can stand the vague sense of inferiority (which will mostly be voiced by a few entitled students) stemming from being neither in New York nor within the inner-circle of HYP, you can find happiness there.
Brown - Probably my favorite Ivy because it so in touch with its Colonial past. Second only to Cornell in the number of buildings that survive from its founding - and its about a hundred years older. Not a lot of Gothic, but it would be my pick if I were really interested in old architecture.
@Morningsider I didn’t apply to Princeton because they required a written essay with teacher’s comments on it but we did ours online, and by the time I knew it was a reuqirement it was too late to rewrite one so I didn’t apply.
I thought it was funny too after getting into the Ivies after Clark rejected me
@Morningsider@Publisher@Bill Marsh @circuitrider
Yeah, I do like the other schools but my parents aren’t letting me go to any of them now that I got into Ivies, and they want one of their kids to go there.
Thanks, I’m black so that’s really helpful. I’ve been hearing that a lot about Penn, I’ve been reading their newspaper articles also and people from there keep complaining about not being in the HYP and being an “Insecure Ivy.” Despite my parents pushing for Columbia, Brown and Penn seem to be pretty top right now. Queens!! But, thanks for understanding
@circuitrider Yeah, like Harvard for example has Harvard Square and all the little shops and houses around it, but it’s still considered urban. If it has like a town around it, just not as intense as being directly in Manhattan.
@Mwfan1921 I like both, I like the freedom Brown gives with their curriculum and how I can choose so many different things cuz I have a lot of different interests. But, I worry if it’s too much because the more people explain or compare the two, I don’t understand. I also like Columbia’s curriculum because I’m interested in the humanities regardless, and would love to take classes in all the core subjects.
I see what you mean. I think you would like Brown’s Thayer Street. The only thing missing is a metro station. Penn has made a rather obvious attempt to replicate a “fake college town” with University City. Unfortunately for some us old timers, we remember what was there before all the red brick and IMO the block upon block of new construction comes across as rather sterile. YMMV.
It’s tough to to say which school has higher prestige for something as general as humanities and social sciences, but if you still intend to major in journalism, then Columbia, maybe by a long shot. Not sure between Penn and Brown. Humanities would be Brown, pre-professional (business, engineering) would be Penn.