The second half of your list is great. Pick one or two from the top half as your reaches (get rid of the other reaches) and add two safeties to round it out. Its hard to find safeties you’ll be happy to attend. Spend the time to find two. Honestly, I don’t think you’ll have to “resort” to a safety because you have a couple of low matches on your list but just in case…
My D ended up attending one of her “safeties” who offered her a fantastic package. She added it to her list in 2014. She will graduate this year and honestly, this school is now a high match/low reach for her stats today. Its crazy.
More to the point, how many students from your school actually end up attending? Dickenson is a popular safety, but nobody likes being seen as a safety. Show them some real love (ie, make the road trip, do the interview)- you don’t want them to reject you simply b/c they don’t believe that you will really come (applies to most of the places that feel as if they should be safeties).
Your list is actually fine in principle- the problem is simply that randomness can hit. That ORM thing is real.
If $$ is not an issue, have you looked at the UK or Ireland? Your stats would make you very likely for Durham, for example. The other significant limiting factor is how sure you are about what you want to study, b/c you go straight into your major there and (with a little wiggle room at Scottish unis) that is all you do (very detailed course descriptions are available online). Not counting Oxford/Cambridge (where an interview process applies), you would be very likely to get some offers before Christmas, but not have to commit until April. It would give you some top tier alternatives.
Otherwise, try looking for one more wild card based on an area of interest- as in, ‘this school isn’t at the prestige level that I see as appropriate for me, but they do have this amazing program that I could do that would make it better than College Park if that was the only choice I had’.
My daughters safety was Saint Michael’s in Vermont and they had early action, although it was the plan, it was nice to have an acceptance in hand before Thanksgiving. That allowed her to be a little more ambitious and the whole process was not overly stressful. Every white female needs to have a few extra low matches on the list.
How about St. John’s College in Annapolis for a safety? Curriculum focused around the Great Books, second campus in Santa Fe NM and I believe they may offer merit aid.
You probably will get into Mac, but, other than that… I would add some safety schools. Frankly, I would be a little worried if you were my kid, because that is such a random assmeblage of schools, some of which don’t have a lot in common, other than “prestige.” … and some of those schools care very much about your “fit.” And there is no way you can be a good fit for all of them, because you have included quite different types of schos.
You probably should add some safeties. There are some really fantastic schools that have the same (and even better) outcomes than the schools you have listed, even though they are not ranked as high. And, as another poster has pointed out, you might even get some merit money from one of them.
One of the best “safeties”, I think is Earlham. You get the same absolutely top-notch education as at the schools on your list, without the stress over admissions. And good merit money, to boot. http://earlham.edu
You could also look at Wooster, Beloit, Kalamazoo, or Bard. Those are solid safeties where you can get a great education.
A really good place to find some solid “safeties” who offer a great education is from the CTCL list. They pick their top 40 schools each year. Here is a link: https://ctcl.org/
It looks like your random list is not all that random - you are picking top schools. But what are you interested in studying? What size setting are you comfortable in? Fit is important. Yale, for example, is no good to you if you are going to be miserable there. You are clearly an excellent student, but there are 36,000 high schools in the US, which means over 36,000 valedictorians alone every year. There are LOTS of excellent students out there.
Follow all the advice given so far - you need some safeties. And not only academic safeties, but financial ones. Learn what your budget is, if you don’t already know and run the net price calculators. College is expensive and you don’t want to be saddled with debt for decades. Or your parents. You sound like an achiever, so you will do well in life no matter where you go because that is who you are. Don’t get too caught up in a “name”.