@Missimperfect I happen to be from New Jersey originally. I lived at the Piscataway apartments, for Rutgers for three summers, while I worked for ATT Bell Labs, and my impression of Rutgers is very positive , for engineering, what I did. I do not know your field, so hard to comment on that at any of these schools. And I have visited Carnegie Mellon last year, and saw the area around Pitt. I think that both of the larger state schools you can choose from will be more lively, potentially but at Case you may be a bigger fish in a smaller pond. It really depends on you, what you want out of college.
There will be a lot of very accomplished students at both Rutgers and Pitt. You may actually have an easier time finding professors to talk with and work for at Case, if you are shy. I think the smaller school has some subtle advantages for shy students.
Also, what about the size of the three departments? So you may get more attention at the smallest department
so you could look that up. It may not be Case, if Pitt or Rutgers has a small cognitive science program.
I picked my major in college because it was a small department, materials science, only about 40 kids in my upper level classes.
It worked out well for me to be in smaller classes.
Also, Honors programs may not really give you much, all depends on the school. So for instance at Arizona State,
its a full separate campus and faculty! At U of Colorado, its a living group for freshman year and many students forgo the extra “capstone” and drop out of it. . At Georgia Tech, a living group, with perks like registration earlier than the masses at GT!
So don’t focus too much on Honors programs, but good you got into them, rather focus on the curriculum, and research and opportunities.
Clearly there could be a lot of great research in your field at all these schools. You should compare them, if you are looking to do research work, and compare the curriculums. Can you get the courses you want and need? Are you premed? Case would be really good for premeds because of all the medical related research. I don’t know about Rutgers or Pitt for that.
Case has the two medical schools, in close proximity, if you are premed, this may be helpful for you.