Ithaca vs. Ball State

College Majors Musical Theater Major
1

<p>I posted this in the Ithaca forum - reposting here as others who have faced one school versus another may have helpful insight.</p>

<p>I know this is a complex question without an easy answer, but I would be curious to get the input of any others that might be wrestling with this question. My S is down to two colleges (unless some miracle school comes in over the next two weeks) - Ithaca and Ball State. We got our Ithaca financial aid package today. Ithaca is roughly $10,000 more a year. This does not include loans at either schools as our goal is ZERO loans in this field of work. The other caveat is that Ithaca price includes grant money based on FAFSA, so depending on annual income that grant amount could change if income goes up at all (and our ability to pay more may not increase at the same pace). Ball State is offering merit scholarship that equates to paying in-state tuition for all four years, so that is unlikely to change dramatically other than annual tuition increases. My S is sold on the fact that Ithaca is a stronger program and therefore worth the extra money (easy to claim when you aren't writing the check). I'm not sure what to think as $40K, and potentially more, is a lot of money...and my husband (who hasn't been involved in this process beyond financially) says go with the cheaper school. Any pearls of wisdom on this front would be greatly appreciated! I'm sure others have made these hard choices, be it at Ithaca or elsewhere.</p>

2

<p>I know money is always a factor, but if your S has visited both schools, where does he feel like he’ll fit in best?</p>

<p>Has he looked at the curriculums to see what classes are offered?</p>

<p>There is a big difference between the midwest and NY culture. Does he prefer one to the other?</p>

<p>My D chose Ball State and has never regretted her decision. The doors it has opened up for her would have never opened anywhere else. She is content being at “the hidden gem of the midwest.” </p>

<p>PM me if you have more questions.</p>

3

<p>Can he visit? What are his criteria for deciding which program is stronger? A visit can really, really clarify things-- there are so many hidden aspects of these programs, and the overall vibe is so important. Spending the money to visit both might be a savings in the long run.</p>

4

<p>On another thread, a parent gave me some sounds advise to see a school that you are interested in by sitting in on current classes, talking to students and teachers and even staying overnight in the dorms. really evaluate what it will feel like. Spending a $1,000 or even $2,000 is nothing compared to a 4-year commitment and price tag for these schools so really check it out.</p>