Ivy League: Should I focus on my sports or musical talents?

I want to apply to the top tier schools. During my Senior year, should I emphasize my athletic background, or my musical talents? I have been in our school’s Varsity Soccer Team (3 years), Varsity Basketball Team (3 years) and Varsity Volleyball Team (1 year). I have participated in our school’s symphony (2 years), been our church’s bassist (4 years), been church’s worship leader (3 years) and Acapella group of Guatemalan/Korean teenagers (1 year).
Thank you!
Have a nice day.

Emphasize whatever you like more.

Why does it have to be one or the other?

They seem equally important – no need to pick one over the other. The only exception would be if you are a recruited athlete then by all means emphasize the athletics.

Three separate sports, none of which you excel at, is unlikely to do you any good.