Music supplement at Yale after playing a few years?

Haydn’s C major concerto is solid, but not virtuoso level (the Daily major is much more challenging).

Your progress has been rapid, but not prodigious. For comparison, junior @anxnymous has been playing for 3 years, and is performing the much harder Dvorak and Shostakovich concertos.

Yes you should submit a supplement, but be aware that you may be on the margin of what would impress.