@xaviermom2017 - thanks for your post. I wanted to call out one part in particular:
I think that’s something that we all need to come to terms with (or not) individually.
When we started this process with my D (my oldest child), she really wanted to go to MIT. It was pretty clear that her chances were in the slim-to-none range. But I thought that if she were to get accepted, that she would do fine there.
As the process went along, I started to see things a little differently. I started to realize that some of the most prestigious schools - even if she was fortunate enough to get in - would not yield the best educational experience for her. And the schools that were the best fit for her were actually match schools.
Now, I actually think this is not necessarily the same for all kids. And in fact parent/child are just making educated guesses about what the best fit is anyway.
But at least for myself / my D, I’ve had to come to the realization that a lot of the desire for prestige is about me, not about D. And seeking maximum prestige / selectivity / whatever for her is actually an anti-goal.
So now my goal is to get her into maximum prestige schools and then boast about how she turned them down…