I’ve lurked here for awhile and followed many of your stories. Right now I am feeling envious of those who have closure and excited kids. We have neither yet (and given the waitlists, we might not even have it on May 1.) I am so ready to buy my sweatshirts. The below is just a vent because I’m so frustrated and worried.
DD1(17) is deciding among Wellesley, Michigan and NYU. She was waitlisted at Berkeley. She almost did ED2 at Wellesley and so when she was admitted I was ecstatic, thinking it was her dream school. (She was rejected from ED1 Pomona, which in the end was good.) And yet….she’s apprehensive, and the doubts only increased after she went to the Spring Open House, where the students were not all that positive about the school. From what I can discern, her main concerns are that it is too isolated and too intense. We live in NYC and so she is accustomed to an urban environment. She deliberately didn’t do ED Chicago because she knows many kids there from her school, and she gets how intense it is, and I think she’s worried that Wellesley will be the same way – kids studying all the time and not having much fun. I know she’s burned out from high school and I think that’s influencing her too. I’ve talked about tradeoffs, and how she can go to Cambridge/Boston on the weekends (where she knows tons of kids) – not to mention the incredible academics, and the alumnae network, and the fact that Wellesley produces these amazing woman. (I watch the fundraising video and get teary.)
Despite the fact that it’s more “fun”, I don’t see her at Michigan at all, actually and I don’t think she does either. We visited last week and while she liked Ann Arbor, she didn’t even want to stay for the Residential College tour. She’s not a “rah rah”/school spirit kind of kid.
She knows many kids at NYU and seems to be leaning towards it. But she didn’t even go to yesterday’s admitted student day! (She said she knows it well enough.) I think NYU would be a mistake for her, and that she should have a campus and get away from NYC. (I suspect she’s also anxious about leaving me.) It’s also more expensive and I don’t see how it’s worth it.
And what happens if she gets off the Berkeley WL?
(Her interests are in the social sciences.)
I want her to choose Wellesley AND be happy about it.
DD2(17), who wants to study political science/law, is currently training as a figure skater in Colorado. Her realistic options now are UMass-Amherst and UCSC. She was waitlisted at GWU and that is her first choice by far. (She got offered the Paris Scholars program at GWU, where she can study in Paris for a year at AUP and then transfer to GWU as a sophomore if she meets the GPA requirements. She has pretty much decided against this option.) I agree that GWU is the right place for her and support it even though it’s more expensive.
But she is now saying that whichever school she ends up at, she wants to defer until the winter term so she can finish this year’s skating season. She hasn’t had the success she had hoped for in skating and now she is in a good training environment, she wants to end on a high note. She says she will go to school in the summer so she can graduate on time.
After years of supporting her skating (despite hating everything about it), I am just done with it. I think it is a mistake to miss the first term of college. But she is an unusual (and mature) kid, and is actually dreading living in a dorm. She’s lived very independently these past few years due to the skating and doesn’t think she’ll fit in with “regular” kids. (Her first choice was NYU so she could live at home, but she was denied. Also denied from Fordham.) She really wants a single wherever she goes and has even said that having a single is the most important factor. So she wants to defer, skate, and then get a single?
I’m just beyond frustrated with both these kids and exhausted after a year of dealing with the admissions process. At the same time, I see how stressful their lives are, and how much pressure is put on them. And they are certainly more tired of the admissions process than I am (especially DD1, who had a lot of rejections along the way.) But in my day (!), we just went to college and adapted. This all seems so indulgent and does not seem to be leading to any increased happiness with their choices, at least for my kids.
Thanks to anyone who read all of this. I know I’m late to the party.