Paying for top tier schools

We have a junior, an only child, who is performing very well in school; GPA 4.0, SAT 2120 taken during sophomore year. We have high hopes for our child and we want to send him to best school possible without hurting our pocket too much. My wife doesn’t work and I currently earn about $24,000 a year. We live off on rental income. Well, during my younger days, I worked, saved hard and purchased rental properties, in prep for my retirement. Current market price is in total 1.1M and I have 300k mortgage on one of them. My primary residence is all paid for, 400k.

I don’t have much in savings. I have tried NPC on several private schools my son wants to attend and because of my rental assets, he doesn’t qualify for much financial aid package and I would have to pay full in-state tuition. To send him to college of his choice, assuming he got accepted, I would have to sell my rental property. I sure could use some financial advice.

Rental properties really hurt the financial aid picture at many schools. It is just a fact of how the financial aid works. It’s your choice to live off rental income. For FAFSA only schools, you may qualify for the automatic $0 or a simplified asset application, but for most private schools the CSS is required, and you have to list the assets.

Many people in your position focus on the high merit schools, either automatic awards (Alabama, Temple, LSU) or at schools that may have a few big merit scholarships (Duke), but with the understanding that those schools are only possible if the student actually wins the scholarship.

He could also try for the national scholarships which are very competitive. Some are available to only low income or minority students, but perhaps they only count income, not assets for qualification.

<<<
My wife doesn’t work and I currently earn about $24,000 a year. We live off on rental income. Well, during my younger days, I worked, saved hard and purchased rental properties, in prep for my retirement. Current market price is in total 1.1M and I have 300k mortgage on one of them. My primary residence is all paid for, 400k.


[QUOTE=""]

[/QUOTE]

Are you saying that you work a job that pays $24k per year AND you have rental income? How much is the rental income?

you have 1.1M in properties…does that INCLUDE your home with the $400k value?

His best bets by far are going to be the big merit schools for high stats mentioned above. There is really no way around the asset issue for CSS profile schools. What is your home state?

Since he’s now only a sophomore and hasaalready demonstrated high performance on the PSAT, make sure he’s ready to do well again when he takes it junior year, to qualify for National Merit Semifinalist. That could unlock some automatic full tuition scholarships at a number of schools.

he’s a junior

<<<
We have a junior, an only child, who is performing very well in school; GPA 4.0, SAT 2120 taken during sophomore


[QUOTE=""]

[/QUOTE]

Whoops, I misread… Well, a 1400 CR+M SAT score could still net him a full tuition Presidential Scholarship at Bama.

But whatever u do, do NOT sell the rental property to simply to indulge his “school of choice”.

Correct. My current job pays 24k and I have hard earned rental properties 1.1M which does not include primary residence… Rental income is about 5000 a month. This is what we live on.

ok…more info…

your income is $84k (combo of job and rental income).

Since you’re suggesting that you’re living on the rental income, that suggests that the $5k per month is net rental income.

1.1M in rental properties with only $300k in mortgage, means equity of $700k

plus $400k of home equity income…

So you have $75k in income per year plus $1M in assets? You aren’t going to do well i the financial aid awards. Stick with merit aid schools.

Residing in Washington…
<<<
His best bets by far are going to be the big merit schools for high stats mentioned above. There is really no way around the asset issue for CSS profile schools. What is your home state?


[QUOTE=""]

[/QUOTE]

This has been real headache for us. A trade off… on one balance son’s education, on the other balance our retirement.

<<<
But whatever u do, do NOT sell the rental property to simply to indulge his “school of choice”.


[QUOTE=""]

[/QUOTE]

So you have $75k in income per year plus $1M in assets? You aren’t going to do well in the financial aid (need) awards. Stick with merit aid schools.

You could take out a mortgage on your rental properties as I am sure you must know.

Here’s a plan: Can you get a job that pays at least $50k? You obviously earned more income earlier in your career to amass all those rental properties. Go back to a higher-paying job.

Second, you wife needs to work (assuming she is not physically unable to do so). If your only child is away at school, your wife will be freed up to do so. Let’s say she makes $35k. With this new scenario, you can pay for college with a combination of next year’s current income, your son’s earnings from summer jobs and part-time work, and the $5.5k student loan your son can take freshman year.

Another idea: Can you sell just one property? If you can add $100k to the pot, that would be a big help.

@brantly

Or the OP’s son could pick a merit school within budget.

Your son is obviously a good student, and I don’t want to diminish his grades and test scores, but if he is thinking about HYPS etc…he really should consider taking the SAT agin, or the ACT and try for a higher score. 2120 is a little on the low side for the very top schools, unless he has some other aspect that is impressive, like a sport, awards, great leadership, and so on. You can look at the mid 50% for colleges he is interested in. To have a better chance ( bearing in mind the chances are not good for anyone) he should aim to be well above 50th, ideally in the 75th percentile.

It sounds like the classic struggle of prestige vs cost

Now is there a way to achieve both?

How about your state flagship for undergrad and then a prestige grad school with a fellowship / graduate assistantship

Bingo all boxes checked

If your wife hasn’t worked for a significant period of time, it’s unlikely she is going to snap up a $35 thousand a year job. She’s most likely going to get something part time, minimum wage.
Look hard at lower ranked, less prestigious school with lots of automatic merit and good honors programs. A few with competitive merit as well would be good as reaches. Seriously, I bet your son could fall in love with some of those automatic merit schools.
What major is he thinking of?

FYI
List of schools granting merit money
http://www.kiplinger.com/tool/college/T014-S001-kiplinger-s-best-values-in-private-colleges/index.php?table=all

Seriously consider Bama. We visited the school and were floored by what we found. S1 was scowling & skeptical when we first arrived for a tour at the honors college. By the end of the visit he said he could see himself going there.