Reputation System Off for Now

Lenitus, that’s exactly what I’ve been doing. Sorry if I wasn’t clear that I was recommending downloading as a technique for saving PMs. I also get them via email, but don’t save all of those. Gmail has virtually unlimited storage.

Hi sabaray…my mistake. I read “it is” as “is it”, even though you didn’t have a question mark at the end. I think I need to increase my font size!

Roger is a pushover. He doubled the mail box size.

Lol-- I definitely didn’t understand this system. I would like comments, but never leave a comment. I was a lonely one green bar girl and one morning I woke up and there were three green bars. I had no idea why. But secretly, I was kind-of happy. The bars did not influence my future comments or change how I read other people’s comments. I agree with someone above about knowing who the consistently helpful folks are. One thing that I do think would be useful would be a thread about the “best” threads of all time in the parent cafe. For example, I followed Sunrise’s posts for a long time. Someone mentioned that they hoped she would meet another poster --Latetoschool–who had died in heaven. I then searched that poster, and read an amazing and sad thread about a woman suffering from lung cancer and the support she received and her interesting perspectives. So, an all time greatest threads list would be helpful.

I was wondering how I had 51 messages! I was so confused lol.

Ty, mods :slight_smile:

Hey, Roger-- Thanks!!

My two cents

Possibility one: Make the total reputation a person can give be based on his number of posts/word count contributed. This way, it would be harder to game the system.

Possibility two: As others have mentioned, make posts rather than users likable.

Thanks for the input, “bubbles”! :slight_smile:

After decades spent on different bulletin boards I’ve seen lots of way to do it. One of my favorite boards is a railroad industry board called yardlimits.com. (son is a RR employee). I like their graphically designed quote and multi-quote buttons and really like their “Thanks” button - similar to liking a post, you thank them for their contribution.

<a href=“http://www.yardlimits.com/forums/images/styles/yardlimits/buttons/post_thanks.gif[/url]”>http://www.yardlimits.com/forums/images/styles/yardlimits/buttons/post_thanks.gif&lt;/a&gt;

The number of thanks a poster has received is listed on each of their posts. That “reputation” part is not what I think is most important though. It’s the posts with lots of thanks attached I pay most attention to. A very popular post will have multiple “thanks” associated with it - lending more creedence to that information.