School in the 2020-2021 Academic Year & Coronavirus (Part 1)

I’m sure a lot of schools simply can’t afford to offer 2 versions of every class no matter how large or small. Or they could just force everyone to have remote-only with no in-person classes, which no one seems to want.

To me, there is a world of difference between trying to accommodate a student or students who are in quarantine/isolation (already done that) and offering a second complete take-your-pick-on-any-given-day course. There is zero way I would agree to that option for my courses. I’m in or I’m out or some of each. I’m not both simultaneously.

Regarding the vaccine, schools that have invited all students back are also providing flu shots and requiring all students on campus to take the flu shots provided by the school. Williams is providing flu shots to all students this week.

Hmm, it did not seem that classes were being offered twice. It looked like some in person classes let students opt to remote into the classroom (and those students were projected onto screen in classroom), or the class was recorded so that students in that class could access at a later time if unable to attend at that time. So in other words, synchronous remote class + some in person.

I forget is it U Chicago or which school that showed on their website a picture of students on a large screen and some students sitting in classroom spaced apart. Instructor was somewhere in between where they could see both sets of students.

Anyway, an institution would have to have the funding and technology capabilities to make this workable. Even so, it would require patience and effort on everyone’s part too.

This is what I’m doing at my LAC. I didn’t have to double my teaching load. Our classrooms have been outfitted with advanced technology. There is a large screen/monitor in the room where the in-person class can see the remote students through Zoom, and a smaller screen/monitor that is focused on the room so the remote students can see the class. There is a tracking camera in the back of the room that follows me while I teach, so I don’t need to stand still at the podium. I can write on the board and both sets of students see it clearly. There are microphones suspended from the ceiling and on the walls that pick up our voices so the remote students can hear me and the students in class. Then there are speakers suspended around the room so the class can hear the remote students. None of my students in the classroom need to bring a laptop and log in to Zoom unless I decide I want to do breakout rooms. In that case, they put on headphones/earbuds. I don’t have any international students in my courses this fall, so there are no issues with time zone differences.

I was worried about teaching on campus, but it’s working very well. We still have class discussions with the full group, and everyone can see each other and the classroom. I don’t even need a microphone. I’m very grateful my college spent money on outfitting at least half of our classrooms/lecture halls with the new tech. I prefer teaching in person and this has made it easy for both on-campus and remote students.

well there goes that… RIT is now under yellow alert. There are cases that seemed to stem from when a student left campus and the local area . Today they are testing everyone in Greek housing and one of the on campus apartment complexes. This weekend was suppose to be brick city weekend for the students with events including pumpkin smashing, but I bet most will be cancelled now.

Just a week ago they had gone 2 weeks with out any cases. So all it took was a student leaving the “bubble”

Haverford seems to be fumbling a bit- at least in my daughter’s opinion. Her crew team’s coach has tested positive for covid and the school was all over the place with guidance on the situation. They ended up falling on placing the captains only in isolation, with the captains rather than the school asking others from practice to quarantine in their own rooms. Only the captain a are being tested as well. She has no idea how it ended up being just the captains when everyone was practicing together with the coach- who isn’t listed as a positive on the website anywhere. Maybe he’s a volunteer? It hasn’t inspired confidence.

It will be interesting if they get to the bottom of this and that is what took place.

DS just returned from his residential BS where students were allowed to travel to nearby restaurants, stores, etc but there was a high-level of mask and social distance requirements. There was only one false positive after over a month on campus.

I think residential colleges will be towards the front of the line to procure Covid vaccine for their students/staff/faculty. Congregate living would be the justification.

(I hope) they’ll be shortly behind healthcare/frontline workers and seniors/preexisting conditions.

@ProfSD - thanks for sharing the example about how your classes are working. I believe that many students are having meaningful educational experiences this year, especially the way you describe your courses. My D’s classes at her LAC sound similar and she is very much enjoying being back on campus despite the restrictive bubble. Yes, it’s not ideal and it’s much different from last year, but it’s good to see colleges adapting and moving forward in creative ways.

However, residential (and other) colleges have some mitigations available, such as online / distance education.

But there are others in jobs or situations where mitigations are less available or effective, such as those working in:

  • Meat packing.
  • Restaurants with crowded kitchens.
  • K-8 teaching.
  • Many military service jobs.

Makes sense people on a college board would expect colleges to get higher priority for vaccines. People on other boards for different subjects/walks of life probably would disagree.

https://www.statnews.com/2020/09/01/u-s-advisory-group-lays-out-detailed-recommendations-on-how-to-prioritize-covid-19-vaccine/

Teachers and staff in phase two in this report.

Agreed. No matter what the distribution plan, some people will be unhappy.

For example, some people are advocating to vaccinate all of the world’s health care and first-line workers, before anyone else gets vaccinated. Don’t think that would go over well in the US, at all.

It is Mountain Day at Williams. From FB:
“Classes are canceled, and students are encouraged to get outside and explore via a multitude of outdoor activities including small-group hikes, yoga, an ergathon, live performances, and (of course) apple cider and donuts.”

I am starting to think they might last the semester on campus…

@saillakeerie I think they probably would be at least some level of priority because of congregate housing and the risk of spread in the surrounding communities, as we are witnessing now.

And, obviously, colleges have proven that they are causes of spikes and no one wants spikes.

They have reworked Mountain Day this year with smaller group hikes and social distancing outside. Nice to see these traditions continue notwithstanding COVID, these are the memories that COVID should not displace.

Do any of you think that once the older population (some of the professors in our situations) is able to get a vaccine, we will be able to stop worrying so much about the case numbers on the college campus?

Davidson has joined the New England colleges “Mountain Day” tradition of a surprise day off by cancelling all classes and practices today. There were happy shouts in the dorms at midnight when the email went out.

My freshman forwarded a NYTimes piece entitled “The First Semester of College Has Never Been Stranger”. A brief excerpt:

"Elle Fleenor didn’t know a soul when she first set foot on the campus of Butler University in Indianapolis — wearing a mask, of course — and hunkered down for two weeks of quarantine. She attended orientation and lectures on Zoom, picked up food from the dining hall to eat in her room, and barely interacted with anyone beyond her dorm building’s walls.

Ms. Fleenor, a first-year student from Scottsburg, Ind., knew college wouldn’t be what she had imagined. But she wasn’t prepared for how the precautions her school was taking to slow the spread of the coronavirus would complicate her efforts to make friends, and how isolated that would make her feel.

Sometimes, she said, she would meet someone in an online class but wouldn’t recognize the person later wearing a mask around campus.

“It’s been very hard, very lonesome,” Ms. Fleenor said. “As a freshman, being hit with all this is extremely difficult.”

Across the country, millions of first-year students are adjusting to college during a pandemic. That means classes conducted mostly online, dinners in dorm rooms and a hard time getting to know professors and peers. Some look forward to fleeting moments to be with others, like elevator rides. Others force themselves to take walks to be sure they see sunlight.

The first semester of college is challenging even in normal times, as students get used to being away from home, their families and lifelong friends. This year, psychologists and other experts fear that the necessary precautions taken by colleges and universities, many of them coronavirus hot spots, will increase the loneliness and isolation…"

@shuttlebus No, because covid spills over into college towns. Most universities are totally porous and/or integrated into the community around them. Schools like Amherst, Williams, etc are the exception.