<p>I think it’s not so much the choice of major that is the conundrum, but rather the choice of liberal arts vs art school. </p>
<p>It sounds to me that your daughter (and her parents) would prefer the liberal arts education. Nothing wrong with path – and it could turn out that’s there a lot right with it – but she has to be aware that a BA degree in visual arts from an “all purpose” college or university may not be a direct link to an advertising / graphic arts career. She may be able to compensate by landing industry internships and summer jobs or by taking a one to two year technical design course or getting an MFA on top of her BA. </p>
<p>On the other hand, the positives of a broad liberal arts education are many, including honing skills such as oral and written communication, analysis and presentation, that will serve her well in the world of work. Along the way she can pick up some art history, economics, political science, psychology and other disciplines that will provide background for commercial design creativity.</p>
<p>I think that while some high school students really do know what they want to do with the rest of their lives, many just feel they need to name a familiar career – doctor, lawyer, engineer – when, really, they have no idea what all’s out there. A facility for drawing and an interest in design could lead in a lot of different directions in addition to the obvious, so she’ll want to leave the doors open until she’s had a chance to learn more about her options.</p>
<p>So, ultimately the choice between liberal arts and Art with a capital A is hers. Does she want to focus on art 24/7, surrounded by others doing the same? Or does she want a balance of academics and arts in a diverse campus community? </p>
<p>Some other small liberal arts colleges in the Northeast that have good visual arts department (though not specifically in design) are Wesleyan, Conn College, Skidmore, Hamilton. Also Williams, though it’s very selective. All of these, plus the others on your list, will have alumni/ae who have excelled in art and design careers, though not at the same percentage as graduates from schools like MICA or RISD.</p>
<p>Hopefully, over the next two years she’ll be able to do some visiting and to talk to professionals in the field in order to make the decision clearer.</p>