We are conflicted
which school is stronger academically?
I know this is a little late but SHP is definitely stronger. SHP’s average SAT is 1880 while SPP’s is 1820. SHP also holds the higher ACT average at 29 while SPP holds a 28. Seton Hall also sends far more students to top 20 colleges than SPP.
A difference of 60 points on SAT and 1 point on ACT doesn’t seem significant to me. I don’t know those schools, but there are likely better ways to compare them if a student is interested in both.