<p>Just to add/emphasize-</p>
<p>Amherst coaches in general must be very forthcoming-our S was told that the entire athletic program, with boys, girls and football had 45 “Slots”. Our son’s sport had 4 for men and women. Coach said our S wasn’t needed enough(based on his roster and our S’s event) to give a slot, but he would give him a “tip”, which means they tell admissions they would like the student, but can’t give any other weight to the application. He told my S he should (along with his 4.0 IB average, top 5%, team captain 2 years, 4 year varsity) retake the ACT(31) to be more competitive.</p>
<p>Williams coach strung my S along until the last minute for ED applications then either had a better prospect who didn’t get a likely letter, or the lack of 700s on my S’ achievement tests (all 600s) caused his “walk-thru” to result in a “probably won’t get in ED, please apply RD”</p>
<p>Midd coach did the walk-thru, said “you look great” and that is where is he now-but Midd requires only 1 set of standardized tests, so the aforementioned “non-competitive” SAT2s never had to surface.</p>
<p>Other schools recruited him heavily, but those were his top 3 choices.</p>
<p>If you’re going D3, insist on a “walk-thru” with admissions before you send in that ED application. Not everyone who gets recruited or invited for a visit gets admitted. There was a very sad Amherst football recruit on these boards last December.</p>