Academically they are even outside of Eng and CS majors (Stanford adv) and some hum majors (Princeton adv). And we shouldn’t use grad school rankings to assign perceived differences in undergrad program quality.
Something nobody else has mentioned that I think is an advantage for Princeton in this case:
More focus on undergraduates.
Stanford is a great school but fewer than 50% of the students are undergrads. Meanwhile, about two-thirds of Princeton students are undergrads.
What does this mean, you ask?
- Princeton is more likely to care about what undergrads want and will work harder to satisfy them.
- Undergrads at Princeton are more likely to have a chance at research opportunities since there are fewer grad students to compete with.
- Top professors at Princeton are more likely to spend time with undergrads, since there are fewer grad students (and grad classes...) competing for their time.
- The overall feel of the school is shaped mostly by undergrads, since they comprise the vast majority of the students.
If the other school were Harvard, or MIT, or Columbia – schools with markedly lower proportions of undergrad students than Princeton – I’d be saying the same thing. (or, say, Brown vs. Duke…)
In terms of the Wall Street pipeline: Stanford is good, but Princeton is better – Princeton grads have been among the most sought on Wall Street for over 100 years, right up there with Harvard, Wharton and Yale.
In terms of fit, cost and academic fit are of the utmost importance. There are also location/environment and social vibe/scene to think about, if they’re important to you.
I don’t know anything about marine biology other than the most basic things (life forms in water. lol) – if it turns out that Stanford’s program is miles better than Princeton’s, obviously that makes academic fit at Stanford better. But if you aren’t sure about major, or if you were to change your mind, the schools are even in overall academic quality. In terms of undergrad focus, Princeton has the edge. For Silicon Valley, Stanford has it. And for Wall Street, both are good, but Princeton has it.