<p>I have visited Knox, Kalamazoo, Lawrence and Beloit of these schools. My older son attends Kalamazoo and loves it. It is a “work hard, play hard” school from what I can tell, where the faculty expects a lot from the students. The facilities are good and the campus, sited on a hill, is very attractive. The library is gorgeous and the student center just finished a major remodeling project. The student body ranges from quirky to preppy, with a bulge of more “typical” kids in between. The city of Kalamazoo is big enough to provide some additional amenities (shopping, restaurants, transportation options) to the students. The school has a very profound focus on international experience, with 85% of students studying abroad for one or two quarters as juniors.</p>
<p>Lawrence is quite similar, except replace the international focus (although more than half of Lawrence’s students do study abroad at some point) with a music focus owing to the integrated conservatory that enrolls about a quarter of LU’s students. Lawrence has very good facilities also, especially its academic buildings, which are mostly very new, and a very pretty campus sited above the Fox River in Appleton. It is about to complete a beautiful new campus center (union). (We visited with my younger son very recently.) Appleton, like Kalamazoo, provides some reasonable off-campus amenities for the students, and like Kalamazoo it has a regional airport. The student body comes from a broader footprint nationally and internationally than the other three schools.</p>
<p>Beloit is a little more “crunchy granola” in its student body composition. Like the others it has a very pretty campus (also sited above a river, although without the vistas that Lawrence enjoys). Its facilities are a bit more worn, except it just opened a spectacular new science center that is probably the most impressive academic building at any of these schools. Its library is very attractive also. More so than Kalamazoo and Lawrence, all its dorms are located together. (When we visited recently with my younger son, he took one look at the dorm quad and grinned, saying that he could already imagine “major snowball fights.”) The city of Beloit doesn’t provide as much off-campus attraction to students, however, and it can be difficult to get to, as there is no train service (unlike Kalamazoo and Knox), and no local airport (although it’s only an hour or an hour and a half away from three airports – in Madison, Chicago and Milwaukee.</p>
<p>Knox struck us as having the most “ordinary” student body of “typical” midwestern kids, although I believe it actually has a better percentage of minority students than the other three. Its campus is a bit more spread out, and as it’s located on the flat terrain of western Illinois, it doesn’t quite have the visual appeal of the others, although it’s certainly attractive. Galesburg, like Beloit, is a smaller, older town that doesn’t provide as much to do off campus, but frequent trains to Chicago make it easy to get to (that’s a three hour ride, however). The academic buildings are mostly older. The rec facilities on campus are probably the best of the four schools, however, including a beautiful new workout facility for students.</p>
<p>These are four excellent LACs. By rankings they are all just a notch behind Carleton, Macalester and Grinnell among midwestern colleges, but the truth is that if you took any of those seven schools and transplanted them whole to Pennsylvania, New York or New Hampshire, many, many more people would be waxing poetic about them on CC.</p>