<p>As this is my 1000th-senior-member-post, I'm going to make it really count.
[quote]
...anyone applying to any school just for the free t-shirt they get is just pathetic.
[/quote]
You've completely missed the point. This is not to encourage people to apply for a free t-shirt, it is to raise awareness that the university exists at all. Y'all may think Princeton has no need for more promotion, but let me tell you this: on a global scale, Princeton-awareness lags way behind Yale, Harvard, MIT and Stanford. There are thousands of brilliant qualified students around the world who have the strong qualities that Princeton is looking for, yet because an adcom never visits their region, because they couldn't apply using the common application (until recently), because the few students who do get in to Princeton from their area have little publicity (unlike their fellow-student who is accepted into Yale and who gets to walk around Kazhakistan in their "Yale Rocks" t-shirt), because of all these lack-of-promotion effects, Princeton's true potential is somewhat undermined.</p>
<p>
[quote]
People who are qualified to be Ivy KNOW they are, and are already applying to it, so you're just inflating numbers of non-qualified applicants.
[/quote]
Is it really true that anyone who has the slightest chance of getting into Princeton KNOWs they have that chance? Really? All the inner city minorities? The music virtuosos from villages in Venezuela? Even the small-town guy who loves caring for the elderly in his community, and saves drowning cats from the town river? All these kids KNOW they have a shot at Princeton? They KNOW they've got what it takes to get into the "upper-crust bastion of legacy"? They KNOW the breakdown of Princeton's admission statistics, have calculated their chances to a .009% differential, and have the absolute confidence to decide to apply?</p>
<p>Somehow, I don't think so.</p>
<p>These are the great kids that are overlooked by sweeping generalisations like: "People who are qualified to be Ivy KNOW they are, and are already applying to it, so you're just inflating numbers of non-qualified applicants."
Beleive it or not, there are people out there who just don't KNOW they have what it takes; a little recruitment, a little money spent on encouraging these well-deserving kids to apply is a step in the right direction.</p>
<p>If you are worried that Princeton is competitive enough already because you have your own RD acceptance chance to consider, then think again. There happen to be other people out there in the world, and they deserve the same chance to learn about Princeton as you do. Not everything revolves around "yield" and "selectivity", you know. There are larger global implications to be considered here.</p>